The toning works fine for me. I'm having a difficult time determining the subject in the first photo. The compositional technique of the second photo to hone in on the foreground detail is nice but I encourage you to look for other scenes that allow you to place even greater emphasis on that area of the image.
Binnur, while I think the sepia works well, is it possible to tone down the sepia? To me it kind of comes across a bit too strong in color (tone?).
As for the two images, I like #1. It has a very pastoral feel to it and to my mind the view is the subject. On the other hand #2 just seems...bland.
Thank you Mike and Jack for viewing and commenting
Mike for #2, I will try some other shots with sea and some plants in the foreground and upload them to CIC. After a while I get bored working on the other shots of the same scenery and that's why I think that, it is better to move on to another place and scenery and to try to improve myself there. Thank you very much for your valuable comments. What I understand is that, I'm not doing bad for the time being and my route is not wrong. So, good enough for me For #1 I don't actually have a main subject in the image, I like the pastoral look in the scenery as Jack says.
Jack, I will try to tone down the sepia if I can. I'm new into using some colour effects in PP so I will have to make trials for toning it down ( or may be I can do it playing with levels, I will see. ). So, if I can get something decent I will upload it for you My goal in #2 was actually to have some foreground objects like flowers and bushes but it seems that I couldn't get the exact effect I wanted , so I will try it again with other shots.
I like them, looks like a scene you'd see from a train.
The sepia works just fine for me, and works with these shots.
I'm with John on this. Reminds me of when I was a kid taking the steam train across England.
Thank you John and Ken. I'm glad that you liked the images
Hi Binnur, I think the sepia effect works well for these images
Thank you David
Binnur, I really like these and you sepia effect is better than the effect I achieved last weekend on my Granny's Bonnet - would be interested in how you got there.............................
I particularly like the 2 - the foreground is just dominant enough to lead the eye through the scene whereas the 1 doesn't quite achieve this.
Thank you Kaye I use PS CC and there is a sepia option in the 'hue and saturation' layer. I converted the image with this option. But before converting it I first edited in ACR and then I used the 'softlight' blending mode according to my taste in PS side. I also made some other adjustments like curves, levels according to what changes the image needs. I hope this helps
they are really excellent; the monotone really works here; things look very sharp
Thank you Nandakumar
Nice work Binnur, I like the sepia but maybe tone down just a bit.
I also prefer the toned-down version but this is really a matter of personal preference, not authenticity. As an example, the three sepia presets that are shipped with Lightroom don't resemble anything that I would consider a classic sepia look. The fact that Lightroom ships three of them speaks volumes that there is no particular toning that all so-called sepia images should be to be considered sepia.
Thank you Mike In the hue and saturation layer in PS CC, if you choose sepia option ,preset value for hue is 35 and preset value for saturation is 25. I just decreased the saturation a bit for the toned down version. So, it can be adjusted according to the personal preference as you said.
Even when using my own custom sepia preset that I designed according to my likes, I often have to adjust it somewhat depending on the photo. Very often it's a matter of only changing the opacity but sometimes I tweak the color just a bit.