Originally Posted by
CNelson
I like these images, especially #2. More like photo art than traditional photography but photo art is increasingly becoming part of a new traditional photography. I like what people are doing with photography these days.
I think the essence of what Colin said in another post is true. The photographer (phartist) creates something that pleases him/herself and others have their own positive or negative interaction with the image. One can't say that chocolate ice cream is better than strawberry ice cream in a transcendent way, yet one can say I like chocolate or strawberry with accuracy.
Now, having said that, I will say there is such a thing as bad art or bad photography. Bad art can be recognized by a consensus just as a bad taste in ice cream can. All of this to say that posting images here is helpful to the aspiring phartist because the reactions and suggestions of others help us to see our work through other eyes. We may not always agree with what others see or say about our work because the comments are usually one man/woman's opinion. However, sharing with other photographers with varying skill levels helps us identify blind spots and reinforce what is good about our work. One thing that I appreciate here is that others see small details that I may not have noticed because I'm usually looking at a total image and in so doing, I miss small details that need attention.
Sorry for getting windy Professional, the first paragraph says it all for me. I particularly like #2...the overall effect is dramatic.
Chuck