'fraid this one isn't doing it for me, Chris.
I think may be the angle of the shot (from quite high above?) is dampening the effect/impact of water crashing into the shore. There's nothing that my eye can grab onto and as a result it's sort-of wandering all over the image.
I just wonder if the darker area of sea is a little too heavy, and perhaps over sharp compared with the surf. When I cover up that area, which produces a 2 x 1 ratio crop (approx) the surf and shore looks a lot better.
Chris I like them both. I enjoy that they are not "fluffy". I think they convey the power of the water against the rocks.
Both of them are a true reflection of the area you were. They are exactly how I remember them. Good shots.
Chris
Interesting that you posted this because I was editing some shots I took last week, and was reminded by one of them (below) how weird the sea can be in relation to the land. In your shot the sea looks quite encroaching on the land, and in mine the sea looks like a giant pool of water that has just flowed in from no-where. I've always found this sort of thing very weird, and I do have a fear of the sea, probably for that reason. The sea is something we usually take for granted, and because we are used to seeing it apparently fitting in well with the edge of the land we tend to forget that there is always a struggle going on between the power of the sea and the land.
And that scene could just as easily look like mine given a North Atlantic bruiser blowing through. Like you, while I love to sail and shoot the never ending variations in the sea and shore, the ocean always gives me a case of the heebie-jeebies. In my first shot which Donald didn't like, it was as close as I could get without fear of being sucked over the edge.....and trust me, I was very-very wary.
I do so love the serenity of one this one minute justaposed against the potential of an opposite reaction, the next.