I think I like no. 2 best for the detail in the wood and the metal. Maybe a bit of pruning of the grass heads might assist next time and possibly a tad of straightening as I feel I am leaning over to the left? No.1 would be better if not so central in the frame? The square crop doesnt do it justice.
I'd go along with that.
I like the idea of the landscape that has the river in it, but feel it needs to show more detail in that far bank. It's maybe a bit too dark and flat. I think it needs a slight counter-clockwise rotation as well to level it up (or is that an optical illusion?).