I think the lighting is wonderful Colin.
Wow, that is a great image. I like the colors in it as well, very nicely composed. My only nit is the debris on the beach in the yellow reflection area. I think removing that would eliminate the distraction it creates.
Like it a lot Colin. A great find! Agree with Pierre: try a crop to get rid of the two bottom 'lonely' rocks.
Looks good to me.
beautiful image Colin,
perhaps, in my humble opinion, the stones on the right are too dark to see details or too bright to be a silhouette...
cheers
Nicola