Don't know what software you use for post processing. But in terms of going for a the dark/moody look, I feel this is too 'nice'. The lighting is okay fro getting that, but that straight head-on pose with the person (is it a self-portrait?) not looking very mean or moody doesn't add to the atmosphere. Also (and this is where the question about software comes in) adding in some hard film grain could also contribute to creating that 'harder edge' to the image.
Boo - I can't view photobucket files
Joshua: I have to agree with Donald, it looks to clean to me. That is not to say that it is not a great image, is it, I love that deep rich black you have in the image, however there are a number of spot on the young man's face that are just to bright for my liking. The young man has a little stubble on his chin and lower jaw, darken that up to help bring up some shadow in that area. With an B&W image you only have black, white and the tones in between, you have great black and white but are missing those tones to fill in the between they help to get that moody and gritty look.
I have tried to add some of what I said by adding a layer maske and doing some burning and a little dodging.
If you do not like what I have done I will remove the adjusted image.
Cheers:
Allan
Joshua,
To be honest, I keep searching for a little bit of left side in the face.
Try another shot , same set up with the light not coming from straight left, but move the light a bit lower and shoot the light up the face of the sitter....does not have to be too low, a bit a low will give you the effect of dark and mean.
Also I agree that a bit light on the leftside will make the picture compelling.