Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast
Results 21 to 40 of 47

Thread: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

  1. #21
    rpcrowe's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Southern California, USA
    Posts
    17,406
    Real Name
    Richard

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    Doesn't this seem somewhat like "Photo Contests" in which the sponsors charge an entry fee and the photos entered become the "property" of the contest sponsors.

    That IMO is a lose-lose proposition for the photographers entering those contests (except for the few winners) and a win-win for the sponsors.

    That said, I am reluctantly (very reluctantly) evolving into the 21st Century Cyber World because so much dog adoption business is carried out on FaceBook...

  2. #22

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    17,660
    Real Name
    Have a guess :)

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    Quote Originally Posted by rpcrowe View Post
    Doesn't this seem somewhat like "Photo Contests" in which the sponsors charge an entry fee and the photos entered become the "property" of the contest sponsors.
    Not quite -- they're not asking folks to give them the images -- just asking folks to agree that they can use them for targeted advertising.

    I thing folks need to remember the other side of the equation ... do they have any idea of the costs involved in setting up / using data centers all over the world and employing tens of thousands of people to create a product that they then GIVE AWAY. At the end of the day, it's a business that needs to make money somehow -- and this is one of the ways they do it. It can't just be a one-sided transaction -- there has to be something in it for them.

  3. #23

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    17,660
    Real Name
    Have a guess :)

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    Finally some more rational thinking on the "scandal of 2012"

    http://www.stuff.co.nz/technology/di...ise-user-rules

  4. #24
    Karl's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Location
    Rockingham, Western Australia
    Posts
    178
    Real Name
    Karl

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    I only wish that my images were good enough for someone to want to try and sell (or even steal) them

    I use Facebook to keep in touch with family all round the world and I participate in a number of Groups and put my photos up - but they are low res and have a watermark (yes I know they can be removed) but I never put up any image that I think might be of value.

    I suppose on the upside of this is at least they tell you they are going to do it - there are a lot of people / corporations etc out there that are happy just to take any image they wish from any website and not even tell you to use for their own purpose

    Karl

  5. #25
    Ady's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    Cambridgeshire
    Posts
    179
    Real Name
    Adrian Asher

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    Quote Originally Posted by Colin Southern View Post
    At the end of the day, it's a business that needs to make money somehow... there has to be something in it for them.
    I think a lot of users of social media and other 'free' online services fail to recognise (or just plain forget) that Facebook, Google, Yahoo etc. are businesses with responsibilities to owners/shareholders, creditors, the tax man etc... all of which come BEFORE their responsibilities to their non-paying user base. Without finding ways to commercialise their customer base all such services would need to be paid for at the point of use. The most common model seems to involve making you (or more specifically the commercially valuable user data you generate) the product, while the advertisers (and anyone else who is prepared to pay for the data) become the clients.

    Personally I prefer to be the client and to pay up front for services, in return I expect transparent charging and a clear and binding contract. I know such contracts are often not worth the paper they are written on, but you only have to look at the past and present behaviour of providers of online services to recognise that they are considerably more circumspect with their treatment of contracted, paying customers than they are with their 'free to use' users.

    While the advertising on CinC is the least intrusive of all the forums and tutorial sites that I've come across I would be happy to pay a subscription for the excellent service that CinC provides, not only to cover the infrastructure and data costs but also to provide some recompense for the efforts that the admins, mods and tutorial authors put in, without which CinC would not be the place it is.

    Many thanks and a happy holiday to all of those who give their time to make this pleasant and considerate place work as well as it does.

    Cheers,
    A

  6. #26
    Andrew76's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Location
    Ontario, Canada
    Posts
    1,300
    Real Name
    Andrew

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    Thank you for having a logical, realistic approach to the world, Colin.

  7. #27
    Mito's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    Location
    Costa Blanca, Spain
    Posts
    222
    Real Name
    Brian

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    "No publicity is bad publicity". That said "misinterpretation" is a poor excuse for making a cock-up in the first place especially when it is made by a supposedly intelligent person.
    The thing that upsets me is that they can, or are trying to take someones work without any compensation at all. Yes Instagram is a business but surely they could have the good maners to ask before taking and inform the owner of the intended use for the photo and at least give the owner the option to say no. I would be proud to have a photo used but I want to be credited with that photo.
    To me it yet another example of mega-businesses trying to control and worse, removing the right of choice.

  8. #28

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    17,660
    Real Name
    Have a guess :)

    Facebook/Instagram DOESN'T want to sell your photos with no compensation to you!

    Quote Originally Posted by Mito View Post
    "No publicity is bad publicity". That said "misinterpretation" is a poor excuse for making a cock-up in the first place especially when it is made by a supposedly intelligent person.
    It's pretty much the same wording that every other similar site uses -- it's probably just the first time that anybody has actually read it. Perhaps you should be concerned about CiC because our code of conduct says that moderators and administrators can edit any post for any reason ... aren't folks concerned that we're not changing things willy nilly and mis-stating peoples intentions on a regular basis?

    The thing that upsets me is that they can, or are trying to take someones work without any compensation at all. Yes Instagram is a business but surely they could have the good maners to ask before taking and inform the owner of the intended use for the photo and at least give the owner the option to say no.
    They're not "taking it" (I'm quite sure you'll still have it) - and I don't think what they're doing is "rude" because they have been quite up-front about it. If they gave people the option then the internet posse would leap into action with a zillion campaigns to "just say no".

    To me it yet another example of mega-businesses trying to control and worse, removing the right of choice.
    Hang on a minute ... it's a FREE service and you very much still have a choice; if you don't like the terms and conditions then don't use the service. Yes - it is a BUSINESS - they have bills to pay and shareholders to satisfy -- BIG bills. I would suggest that it's bloomin hard to pay those bills when you give your services away for free.

    If you ask me, what not fair about all of this is the public general's demands; all take and no give. They're happy to use the service for free, but additionally they also want to set the rules. And even when they're quite up-front about what they intend to do, people's imaginations run wild with a ridiculous mis-interpretation and they get publicly flogged / stoned by the vocal minority.

    They just can't win.

  9. #29

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    17,660
    Real Name
    Have a guess :)

    Re: Facebook/Instagram DOESN'T want to sell your photos with no compensation to you!

    Anything in here folks aren't happy with?
    ADOBE
    Software License Agreement
    PLEASE READ THIS AGREEMENT CAREFULLY. BY COPYING, INSTALLING, OR USING ALL OR ANY
    PORTION OF THIS SOFTWARE, YOU (HEREINAFTER “CUSTOMER”) ACCEPT ALL THE TERMS AND
    CONDITIONS OF THIS AGREEMENT, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, THE PROVISIONS ON
    LICENSE RESTRICTIONS IN SECTION 4, LIMITED WARRANTY IN SECTIONS 6 AND 7, LIMITATION OF
    LIABILITY IN SECTION 8, AND SPECIFIC PROVISIONS AND EXCEPTIONS IN SECTION 16. CUSTOMER
    AGREES THAT THIS AGREEMENT IS LIKE ANY WRITTEN NEGOTIATED AGREEMENT SIGNED BY
    CUSTOMER. THIS AGREEMENT IS ENFORCEABLE AGAINST CUSTOMER. IF CUSTOMER DOES NOT
    AGREE TO THE TERMS OF THIS AGREEMENT, CUSTOMER MAY NOT USE THE SOFTWARE.
    Customer may have another written agreement directly with Adobe (e.g., a volume license agreement)
    that supplements or supersedes all or portions of this agreement. The Software is LICENSED, NOT SOLD,
    only in accordance with the terms of this agreement. Use of some Adobe and some non-Adobe
    materials and services included in or accessed through the Software may be subject to additional terms
    and conditions. Notices about non-Adobe materials are available at
    http://www.adobe.com/go/thirdparty.
    The Software may cause Customer’s Computer to AUTOMATICALLY CONNECT TO THE INTERNET. The
    Software may also require activation or registration. Additional information on activation, Internet
    connectivity, and privacy is available in Sections 14 and 16.
    1. Definitions.
    1.1 “Adobe” means Adobe Systems Incorporated, a Delaware corporation, 345 Park Avenue, San Jose,
    California 95110, if this agreement is entered into while Customer is in the United States, Canada, or
    Mexico; otherwise, it means Adobe Systems Software Ireland Limited, 4–6 Riverwalk, Citywest Business
    Campus, Dublin 24, Ireland.
    1.2 “Adobe Runtime(s)” means Adobe AIR, Adobe Flash Player, Shockwave Player, or Authorware
    Player.
    1.3 “Compatible Computer” means a Computer with the recommended operating system and hardware
    configuration as stated in the Documentation.
    1.4 “Computer” means a virtual or physical device that accepts information in digital or similar form and
    manipulates it for a specific result based on a sequence of instructions, including without limitation
    desktop computers, laptops, tablets, mobile devices, telecommunication devices, Internet-connected
    devices, and hardware products capable of operating a wide variety of productivity, entertainment, or
    other software applications.
    1.5 “Customer” means you and any legal entity that obtained the Software and on whose behalf it is
    used; for example, and as applicable, your employer.
    1.6 “Internal Network” means a private, proprietary network resource accessible only by employees and
    individual contractors (i.e., temporary employees) of a specific corporation or similar business entity.
    Internal Network does not include portions of the Internet or any other network community open to the
    public, such as membership or subscription driven groups, associations, and similar organizations.
    1.7 “Output File” means an output file Customer creates with the Software.
    1.8 “Permitted Number” means one (1) unless otherwise indicated under a valid license (e.g., volume
    license) granted by Adobe.
    1.9 “Software” means (a) all of the information with which this agreement is provided, including but not
    limited to: (i) all software files and other computer information; (ii) any proprietary scripting logic
    embedded within exported file formats or used in an Adobe Online Service; (iii) sample and stock
    photographs, images, sounds, clip art and other artistic works bundled with Adobe software or made
    available by Adobe on Adobe’s website for use with the Adobe software and not obtained from Adobe
    through a separate service (unless otherwise noted within that service) or from another party (“Content
    Files”); (iv) related explanatory written materials and files (“Documentation”); and (v) fonts; and (b) any
    modified versions and copies of, and upgrades, updates, and additions to, such information, provided to
    Customer by Adobe at any time, to the extent not provided under separate terms (collectively,
    “Updates”).
    2. Software License; Membership.
    2.1 Software License. This Section 2.1 applies to Customers who have purchased a license to the
    Software but have not purchased a membership-based license or service such as the Creative Cloud
    membership (as described in Section 2.2).
    2.1.1 License Grant. Subject to Customer’s continuous compliance with this Agreement and payment of
    the applicable license fees, Adobe grants Customer a non-exclusive and limited license to install and use
    the Software (a) in the territory or region where Customer obtains the Software from Adobe or Adobe’s
    authorized reseller or as otherwise stated in the Documentation (“Territory”), (b) during the term of such
    license (“License Term”), (c) within the scope of the License Type and on the Permitted Number of
    Customer’s Compatible Computers as specified in the Documentation, and (d) in a manner consistent
    with the terms of this Agreement and applicable Documentation. Unless otherwise defined in this
    Agreement, in the applicable Documentation, or at the time of purchase, License Term shall be
    perpetual. Upon the expiration or termination of the License Term, some or all of the Software may
    cease to operate without prior notice. Upon expiration or termination of the License Term, Customer
    may not use the Software unless Customer has renewed the license. The license granted herein is
    supplemented by specific provisions in Section 16 as related to the use of certain applicable products
    and components that may be included in the Software such as font software, Acrobat, After Effects,
    Adobe Presenter, Contribute, Flash Player, Flash Builder, Digital Publishing Suite, and Adobe Runtimes.
    2.1.2 License Types.
    2.1.2.1 Non-Serialized Software. The Software, or portions of the Software, that are provided without a
    serial number during the License Term may only be installed and used on any number of Compatible
    Computers as part of an organizational deployment plan during the License Term for demonstration,
    evaluation, and training purposes only, and only if any Output Files or other materials produced through
    such use are used only for internal, non-commercial, and non-production purposes. THE NONSERIALIZED SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED “AS-IS”. ACCESS TO AND USE OF ANY OUTPUT FILES CREATED
    WITH SUCH NON-SERIALIZED SOFTWARE IS ENTIRELY AT CUSTOMER’S OWN RISK.
    2.1.2.2 Evaluation Software. The Software, or portions of the Software, that are provided with a serial
    number designated for “evaluation purposes” or other similar designation (such as Software or a serial
    number supplied as “EVAL” under a separate agreement) (“Evaluation Software”) may only be installed
    and used on Permitted Number of Compatible Computers during the License Term for demonstration,
    evaluation, and training purposes only, and only if any Output Files or other materials produced through
    such use are used only for internal, non-commercial, and non-production purposes. THE EVALUATION
    SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED “AS IS”. ACCESS TO AND USE OF ANY OUTPUT FILES CREATED WITH SUCH
    EVALUATION SOFTWARE IS ENTIRELY AT CUSTOMER’S OWN RISK.
    2.1.2.3 Subscription Edition. For the Software available on a subscription-basis (“Subscription Edition”),
    Customer may install and use the Subscription Edition only on the Permitted Number of Compatible
    Computer during the License Term. Subject to the Permitted Number of Computers for the Subscription
    Edition, Adobe may allow Customer to install and use the most recent prior version of the Subscription
    Edition and the current version of the Subscription Edition on the same Computer during the License
    Term. Customer agrees that Adobe may change the type of Software (such as specific components,
    versions, platforms, languages, etc.) included in the Subscription Edition at any time and shall not be
    liable to Customer whatsoever for such change. Ongoing access to a Subscription Edition requires: (a) a
    recurring Internet connection to activate, renew, and validate the license, (b) Adobe or its authorized
    reseller’s receipt of recurring subscription payments, and (c) Customer’s agreement to subscription
    terms and other additional terms and conditions that are available at
    http://www.adobe.com/go/paymentterms or at the time of purchase. If Adobe does not receive the
    recurring subscription payment or cannot validate the license periodically, then the Software may
    become inactive without additional notice until Adobe receives the payment or validates the license.
    2.1.3 Portable or Home Computer Use. Subject to the restrictions set forth in Section 2.1.4, the
    primary user of the Computer on which the Software is installed under Section 2.1 (“Primary User”)
    may install a second copy of the Software for his or her exclusive use on either a portable Computer
    or a Computer located at his or her home, provided that the Software on the portable or home
    Computer is not used at the same time as the Software on the primary Computer.
    2.1.4 Restrictions on Secondary Use by Volume Licensees. If the Software was obtained under an Adobe
    volume license program or agreement (such as Adobe Volume Licensing) by any licensee other than an
    educational volume licensee, then the second copy of the Software made under Section 2.1.3 must be
    used solely for the benefit and business of that volume licensee.
    2.1.5 Dual Boot Platform. The Software is licensed for use on a specific operating system platform.
    Customer must purchase a separate license for use of the Software on each operating system platform.
    By way of example, if Customer desires to install the Software on both the Mac OS and Windows
    operating system platforms on a device that runs both of those platforms (i.e., a dual boot machine),
    then Customer must first obtain two separate licenses for the Software. This is true even if two versions
    of the Software, each designed for a different operating system platform, are delivered to Customer on
    the same media.
    2.1.6 Distribution from a Server. As permitted by the Documentation, Customer may copy an image of
    the Software onto a Computer file server within Customer’s Internal Network (“Server”) for the purpose
    of downloading and installing the Software onto Computers within the same Internal Network for use
    only as permitted by this Section 2.
    2.1.7 Server Use.
    2.1.7.1 As permitted in a separate purchasing document or Documentation and subject to license
    restrictions stated in this Agreement, Customer may install the Software on a Server only for the
    purpose of allowing an individual from a Computer within the same Internal Network (“Network User”)
    to access and use the Software. The Network User who has access to such Software on the Server is
    referred to as “Server Software User”. The total number of Server Software Users (not the concurrent
    number of users) may not exceed the Permitted Number. By way of example, if Customer has
    purchased 10 licenses of Software (Permitted Number is 10) and Customer elects to install the Software
    on a Server, then Customer can only allow up to 10 Server Software Users the access to the Software
    (even though Customer may have more than 10 Network Users or fewer than 10 concurrent users of
    the Software).
    2.1.7.2 For clarification and without limitation, the foregoing does not permit Customer to install or
    access (either directly or through commands, data, or instructions) the Software: (a) from or to a
    Computer not part of Customer’s Internal Network; (b) for enabling web hosted workgroups or web
    hosted services available to the public; (c) by any individual or entity to use, download, copy, or
    otherwise benefit from the functionality of the Software unless licensed to do so by Adobe; (d) as a
    component of a system, workflow or service accessible by more than the Permitted Number of users; or
    (e) for operations not initiated by an individual user (e.g., automated server processing).
    2.2 Membership. This Section 2.2 applies to Customers who have purchased a membership-based
    license or service such as the Creative Cloud membership (collectively, “Membership”).
    2.2.1 Adobe Online Services Related to the Membership. Subject to Customer’s continuous compliance
    with this Agreement and payment of the applicable membership fees, if any, Adobe grants Customer a
    non-exclusive, Territory-wide and limited right to access and use the Software and related Adobe
    Online Service (as further described in Section 16.4.1) as part of the Membership, subject to the terms
    stated in this Agreement and the Additional Terms of Use (as the term is defined in Section 14.1.3
    below).
    2.2.2 Software License Related to the Membership. Subject to Customer’s continuous compliance with
    this Agreement and payment of the applicable membership fees, if any, Adobe grants Customer a nonexclusive and limited license to install and use the Software: (a) in the Territory, (b) during the period
    that the Membership is current and active (“Membership Term”) and (c) in a manner consistent with the
    terms of this Agreement and applicable Documentation. Upon the expiration or termination of the
    Membership Term, (x) some or all of the Software may cease to operate without prior notice and
    (y) Customer may not use the Software unless Customer has renewed the membership. All terms
    related to the specific Software as stated in this Agreement shall remain effective and continue to apply
    to Customer and its use of such Software.
    2.2.3 Restrictions. Customer agrees to the following additional terms and restrictions related to the
    Membership: (a) Adobe may change the type of Software (such as specific products, components,
    versions, platforms, languages, etc.) included in the Membership at any time and shall not be liable to
    Customer whatsoever for such change; (b) Customer may be required to connect to the Internet and log
    in at any time during the Membership Term; (c) Software may automatically connect to the Internet to
    verify Customer’s Membership without notice at any time; and (d) Customer may not enable or allow
    others to use the Software as Customer.
    2.3 Content Files. Unless stated otherwise in the “Read-Me” files, Documentation, or other license(s)
    associated with the Content Files, Customer may use, display, modify, reproduce, and distribute any of
    the Content Files. However, Customer may not distribute the Content Files on a stand-alone basis (i.e.,
    in circumstances in which the Content Files constitute the primary value of the product being
    distributed), and Customer may not claim any trademark rights in the Content Files or derivative works
    thereof. Nothing stated herein shall affect the ownership of the Software as stated in Section 3.
    2.4 Sample Application Code. Customer may modify the source code form of those portions of the
    Software programs that are expressly identified as sample code, sample application code, code snippets,
    ActionScript class files, or sample components (each, “Sample Application Code”) in the accompanying
    Documentation solely for the purposes of designing, developing, and testing websites and applications
    developed using Adobe software programs; provided, however, Customer is permitted to copy and
    distribute the Sample Application Code (modified or unmodified) only if all of the following conditions
    are met: (a) Customer distributes only the compiled object code versions of the Sample Application
    Code with its application; (b) Customer does not include the Sample Application Code in any product or
    application designed for website development; and (c) Customer does not use the Adobe name, logos,
    icons, or other Adobe trademarks to market its application. Customer agrees to indemnify, hold
    harmless, and defend Adobe from and against any loss, damage, claims, or lawsuits, including attorney’s
    fees, that arise or result from the use or distribution of its application.
    2.5 Programming Languages. The Software may include portions of the ExtendScript SDK and Pixel
    Bender SDK. Subject to the restrictions contained in this Section 2, Adobe grants to Customer a
    nonexclusive, nontransferable, royalty-free license to use the items in the ExtendScript SDK and Pixel
    Bender SDK only for the purpose of internal development of application programs designed to function
    with Adobe products. Except as expressly provided in this Section 2.5, no portions of the ExtendScript
    SDK or the Pixel Bender SDK may be modified or distributed. Customer agrees to indemnify, hold
    harmless, and defend Adobe from and against any loss, damage, claims, or lawsuits, including attorney’s
    fees, that arise or result from such distribution.
    2.6 Documentation Copies. Customer may make copies of the Documentation for its own internal use in
    connection with use of the Software in accordance with this agreement, but no more than the amount
    reasonably necessary.
    3. Intellectual Property Ownership.
    The Software and any authorized copies that Customer makes are the intellectual property of and are
    owned by Adobe Systems Incorporated and its suppliers. The structure, organization, and source code
    of the Software are the valuable trade secrets and confidential information of Adobe Systems
    Incorporated and its suppliers. The Software is protected by law, including but not limited to the
    copyright laws of the United States and other countries, and by international treaty provisions. Except as
    expressly stated herein, this agreement does not grant Customer any intellectual property rights in the
    Software. All rights not expressly granted are reserved by Adobe and its suppliers.

  10. #30

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    17,660
    Real Name
    Have a guess :)

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    4. Restrictions and Requirements.
    4.1 Proprietary Notices. Any permitted copy of the Software (including without limitation
    Documentation) that Customer makes must contain the same copyright and other proprietary notices
    that appear on or in the Software.
    4.2 Use Obligations. Customer agrees that it will not use the Software other than as permitted by this
    agreement and that it will not use the Software in a manner inconsistent with its design or
    Documentation.
    4.3 No Modifications. Except as expressly permitted in Sections 2 or 16, Customer may not modify, port,
    adapt, or translate the Software.
    4.4 No Reverse Engineering. Except as otherwise expressly permitted in Section 16.1, Customer will not
    reverse engineer, decompile, disassemble, or otherwise attempt to discover the source code of the
    Software.
    4.5 No Unbundling. The Software may include various applications and components, may allow access
    to different Adobe Online Services, may support multiple platforms and languages, and may be
    provided to Customer on multiple media or in multiple copies. Nonetheless, the Software is designed
    and provided to Customer as a single product to be used as a single product on Computers as permitted
    herein. Unless otherwise permitted in the Documentation, Customer is not required to install all
    component parts of the Software, but Customer may not unbundle the component parts of the Software
    for use on different Computers.
    4.6 No Transfer.
    4.6.1 CUSTOMER WILL NOT RENT, LEASE, SELL, SUBLICENSE, ASSIGN, OR TRANSFER ITS RIGHTS IN
    THE SOFTWARE (INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION, SOFTWARE OBTAINED THROUGH A WEB
    DOWNLOAD), OR AUTHORIZE ANY PORTION OF THE SOFTWARE TO BE COPIED ONTO ANOTHER
    INDIVIDUAL OR LEGAL ENTITY’S COMPUTER EXCEPT AS MAY BE EXPRESSLY PERMITTED HEREIN.
    4.6.2 Except with regard to Educational Software Products (as defined in Section 16.3), Pre-release
    Software (as defined in Section 16.2), Evaluation Software, not-for-resale copies of the Software, or
    Software obtained through an Adobe volume license program and further subject to Section 4.6.3,
    Customer may permanently transfer all its rights to use the Software to another individual or legal entity
    provided that: (a) Customer also transfers (i) this agreement, (ii) the serial number(s), the Software
    affixed to media provided by Adobe or its authorized distributor, and all other software or hardware
    bundled, packaged, or pre-installed with the Software, including all copies, Updates, and Prior Versions
    (as defined in Section 5, below), and (iii) all copies of font software to such individual or entity;
    (b) Customer retains no Updates, Prior Versions, or copies, including backups and copies stored on a
    Computer; and (c) the receiving party accepts the terms and conditions of this agreement and any other
    terms and conditions under which Customer purchased a valid license to the Software. Additional
    information on transferring volume licensed software is available at
    http://www.adobe.com/go/volumepolicies.
    4.6.3 If the Software requires recurring activation or registration and Adobe grants Customer’s request to
    be exempted from the requirement of such recurring activation or registration, then in addition to the
    restrictions set forth in the Activation Terms (as defined in Section 14.3), then the right to permanently
    transfer as stated in Section 4.6.2 shall terminate immediately upon the grant of such request.
    4.7 No Service Bureau. Customer will not use or offer the Software on a service bureau basis.
    Section 16.6.3 provides a limited exception for font software only.
    4.8 Adobe Runtime Restrictions. Customer will not use Adobe Runtimes on any non-PC device or with
    any embedded or device version of any operating system. For the avoidance of doubt, and by example
    only, Customer may not use Adobe Runtimes on any (a) mobile device, set top box, handheld, phone,
    game console, TV, DVD player, media center (other than with Windows XP Media Center Edition and its
    successors), electronic billboard or other digital signage, Internet appliance or other Internet-connected
    device, PDA, medical device, ATM, telematic device, gaming machine, home automation system, kiosk,
    remote control device, or any other consumer electronics device; (b) operator-based mobile, cable,
    satellite, or television system; or (c) other closed system device. Additional information on licensing
    Adobe Runtimes is available at http://www.adobe.com/go/licensing.
    4.9 Territory. Customer shall only use the Software and access the Adobe Online Services in the
    Territory and in a manner consistent with the activation policy described at
    http://www.adobe.com/go/activation. Adobe may terminate the license granted herein or suspend the
    Membership or access to the Adobe Online Services if Adobe determines that Customer is using the
    Software or Adobe Online Services outside the Territory.
    5. Updates.
    If the Software is an Update to a prior version of Adobe software (the “Prior Version”), then Customer’s
    use of this Update is conditional upon its retention of the Prior Version. Therefore, if Customer validly
    transfers this Update pursuant to Section 4.6, the Customer must transfer the Prior Version along with it.
    If Customer wishes to use this Update in addition to the Prior Version, then Customer may only do so on
    the same Computer on which it has installed and is using the Prior Version. Any obligations that Adobe
    may have to support Prior Versions during the License Term may end upon the availability of this
    Update. No other use of the Update is permitted. Additional Updates may be licensed to Customer by
    Adobe with additional or different terms.
    6. Limited Warranty.
    Except as otherwise stated in a separate agreement between Adobe and a Software licensee, Adobe
    warrants to the individual or entity that first purchases a license for the Software for use pursuant to the
    terms of this agreement that the Software will perform substantially in accordance with the
    corresponding user manual for the Software for the shorter period of (a) the ninety (90) day period or
    (b) License Term following receipt of the Software (“Warranty Period”) when used on the Compatible
    Computer. Non-substantial variation of performance from the user manual does not establish a
    warranty right. This limited warranty does not apply to the following, which are made available AS-IS
    and without warranty from Adobe: (i) patches; (ii) font software; (iii) Pre-release Software, trial, starter,
    evaluation, product sampler, Evaluation Software, and not-for-resale copies of the Software;
    (iv) websites, Adobe Online Services; and Third Party Online Services; (v) Certified Document Services
    (see Section 16); and (vi) any software made available by Adobe for free via web download from an
    Adobe website. All warranty claims must be made, along with proof of purchase, to the Adobe
    Customer Support Department within such Warranty Period. Additional information on warranty claims
    is available at http://www.adobe.com/go/support. The entire liability of Adobe and its affiliates related
    to such warranty claim and Customer’s sole and exclusive remedy under any warranty will be limited to
    either, at Adobe’s option, support of the Software based on the warranty claim, replacement of the
    Software, or, if support or replacement is not practicable at Adobe’s determination, refund of the license
    fee Customer paid for the Software (if any). THE LIMITED WARRANTY SET FORTH IN THIS SECTION
    GIVES CUSTOMER SPECIFIC LEGAL RIGHTS. CUSTOMER MAY HAVE ADDITIONAL RIGHTS UNDER
    LAW WHICH MAY VARY FROM JURISDICTION TO JURISDICTION. ADOBE DOES NOT SEEK TO LIMIT
    CUSTOMER’S WARRANTY RIGHTS TO ANY EXTENT NOT PERMITTED BY LAW. Please see Section 16
    for jurisdiction-specific provisions or contact the Adobe Customer Support Department.
    7. Disclaimer.
    THE LIMITED WARRANTY IN SECTION 6 AND ANY STATUTORY WARRANTY AND REMEDY THAT
    CANNOT BE EXCLUDED OR LIMITED UNDER LAW ARE THE ONLY WARRANTIES AND EXCLUSIVE
    REMEDIES APPLICABLE TO THE SOFTWARE. OTHER THAN THOSE OFFERED AND STATUTORY
    WARRANTIES AND REMEDIES, ADOBE, ITS AFFILIATES, SUPPLIERS, AND CERTIFICATE AUTHORITIES
    (DEFINED BELOW) DISCLAIM ALL WARRANTIES, CONDITIONS, REPRESENTATIONS, AND TERMS,
    EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, WHETHER BY STATUTE, COMMON LAW, CUSTOM, USAGE, OR OTHERWISE AS
    TO ANY MATTER, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO PERFORMANCE, SECURITY, NON-INFRINGEMENT
    OF THIRD PARTY RIGHTS, INTEGRATION, MERCHANTABILITY, QUIET ENJOYMENT, SATISFACTORY
    QUALITY, AND FITNESS FOR ANY PARTICULAR PURPOSE. OTHER THAN SUCH OFFERED AND
    STATUTORY WARRANTIES AND REMEDIES, THE SOFTWARE AND ACCESS TO ANY WEBSITES, ADOBE
    OR THIRD PARTY ONLINE SERVICES, AND CERTIFICATE AUTHORITY SERVICES ARE PROVIDED AS-IS
    AND WITH ALL FAULTS. THIS DISCLAIMER OF WARRANTY MAY NOT BE VALID IN SOME
    JURISDICTIONS. CUSTOMER MAY HAVE ADDITIONAL WARRANTY RIGHTS UNDER LAW WHICH MAY
    NOT BE WAIVED OR DISCLAIMED. ADOBE DOES NOT SEEK TO LIMIT CUSTOMER’S WARRANTY
    RIGHTS TO ANY EXTENT NOT PERMITTED BY LAW. The provisions of Sections 7 and Section 8 will
    survive the termination of this agreement, howsoever caused, but this will not imply or create any
    continued right to use the Software after termination of this agreement.
    8. Limitation of Liability.
    EXCEPT FOR THE EXCLUSIVE REMEDY OFFERED BY ADOBE ABOVE AND ANY REMEDIES THAT
    CANNOT BE EXCLUDED OR LIMITED UNDER LAW, ADOBE, ITS AFFILIATES, SUPPLIERS, AND
    CERTIFICATE AUTHORITIES WILL NOT BE LIABLE TO CUSTOMER FOR ANY LOSS, DAMAGES, CLAIMS,
    OR COSTS WHATSOEVER INCLUDING ANY CONSEQUENTIAL, INDIRECT OR INCIDENTAL DAMAGES,
    ANY LOST PROFITS OR LOST SAVINGS, ANY DAMAGES RESULTING FROM BUSINESS INTERRUPTION,
    PERSONAL INJURY OR FAILURE TO MEET ANY DUTY OF CARE, OR CLAIMS BY A THIRD PARTY, EVEN
    IF AN ADOBE REPRESENTATIVE HAS BEEN ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH LOSS, DAMAGES,
    CLAIMS, OR COSTS. IN ANY EVENT, ADOBE’S AGGREGATE LIABILITY AND THAT OF ITS AFFILIATES,
    SUPPLIERS, AND CERTIFICATE AUTHORITIES UNDER OR IN CONNECTION WITH THIS AGREEMENT
    WILL BE LIMITED TO THE AMOUNT PAID FOR THE SOFTWARE, IF ANY. THIS LIMITATION WILL APPLY
    EVEN IN THE EVENT OF A FUNDAMENTAL OR MATERIAL BREACH OR A BREACH OF THE
    FUNDAMENTAL OR MATERIAL TERMS OF THIS AGREEMENT. Nothing contained in this agreement
    limits Adobe’s liability to Customer in the event of death or personal injury resulting from Adobe’s
    negligence or for the tort of deceit (fraud). Adobe is acting on behalf of its affiliates, suppliers, and
    Certificate Authorities for the purpose of disclaiming, excluding and limiting obligations, warranties, and
    liability, but in no other respects and for no other purpose.
    THE FOREGOING LIMITATIONS AND EXCLUSIONS APPLY TO THE EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE
    LAW IN CUSTOMER’S JURISDICTION. THIS LIMITATION OF LIABILITY MAY NOT BE VALID IN SOME
    JURISDICTIONS. CUSTOMER MAY HAVE RIGHTS THAT CANNOT BE WAIVED UNDER CONSUMER
    PROTECTION AND OTHER LAWS. ADOBE DOES NOT SEEK TO LIMIT ITS WARRANTY OR REMEDIES TO
    ANY EXTENT NOT PERMITTED BY LAW. SEE SECTION 16 FOR JURISDICTION-SPECIFIC STATEMENTS.
    9. Export Rules.
    Customer acknowledges that the Software is subject to the U.S. Export Administration Regulations (the
    “EAR”) and that Customer will comply with the EAR. Customer will not export or re-export the Software,
    directly or indirectly, to: (a) any countries that are subject to U.S. export restrictions (including, but not
    limited to, Cuba, Iran, North Korea, Sudan, and Syria), (b) any end user whom Customer knows or has
    reason to know will utilize them in the design, development or production of nuclear, chemical or
    biological weapons, or rocket systems, space launch vehicles, and sounding rockets, or unmanned air
    vehicle systems, or (c) any end user who has been prohibited from participating in the U.S. export
    transactions by any federal agency of the U.S. government. In addition, Customer is responsible for
    complying with any local laws in Customer’s jurisdiction which may impact its right to import, export or
    use the Software. If Adobe has knowledge that a violation has occurred, Adobe may be prohibited from
    providing maintenance and support for the Software.
    10. Governing Law.
    If Customer is a consumer who uses the Software for only personal non-business purposes, then this
    agreement will be governed by the laws of the jurisdiction which Customer purchased the license to use
    the Software. If Customer is not such a consumer, this agreement will be governed by and construed in
    accordance with the substantive laws in force in: (a) the State of California, if a license to the Software is
    obtained when Customer is in the United States, Canada, or Mexico; (b) Japan, if a license to the
    Software is obtained when Customer is in Japan; (c) Singapore, if a license to the Software is obtained
    when Customer is in a member state of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, Mainland China,
    Hong Kong S.A.R., Macau S.A.R., Taiwan, or the Republic of Korea; or (d) England and Wales, if a license
    to the Software is obtained when Customer is in any jurisdiction not described above. The respective
    courts of Santa Clara County, California when California law applies, Tokyo District Court in Japan, when
    Japanese law applies, and the competent courts of London, England, when the law of England and
    Wales applies, shall each have non-exclusive jurisdiction over all disputes relating to this agreement.
    When Singapore law applies, any dispute arising out of or in connection with this agreement, including
    any question regarding its existence, validity, or termination, shall be referred to and finally resolved by
    arbitration in Singapore in accordance with the Arbitration Rules of the Singapore International
    Arbitration Centre (“SIAC”) for the time being in force, which rules are deemed to be incorporated by
    reference into this section. There shall be one arbitrator, selected jointly by the parties. If the arbitrator is
    not selected within thirty (30) days of the written demand by a party to submit to arbitration, the
    Chairman of the SIAC shall make the selection. The language of the arbitration shall be English.
    Notwithstanding any provision in this agreement, Adobe or Customer may request any judicial,
    administrative, or other authority to order any provisional or conservatory measure, including injunctive
    relief, specific performance, or other equitable relief, prior to the institution of legal or arbitration
    proceedings, or during the proceedings, for the preservation of its rights and interests or to enforce
    specific terms that are suitable for provisional remedies. This agreement will not be governed by the
    following, the application of which is hereby expressly excluded: (x) the conflict of law rules of any
    jurisdiction, (y) the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods, and
    (z) the Uniform Computer Information Transactions Act, as enacted in any jurisdiction.
    11. General Provisions.
    If any part of this agreement is found void and unenforceable, it will not affect the validity of the balance
    of this agreement, which will remain valid and enforceable according to its terms. This agreement may
    only be modified in writing, signed by an authorized officer of Adobe. The English version of this
    agreement will be the version used when interpreting or construing this agreement. This is the entire
    agreement between Adobe and Customer relating to the Software and it supersedes any prior
    representations, discussions, undertakings, communications, or advertising relating to the Software.
    12. Notice to U.S. Government End Users.
    12.1 U.S. Government Licensing of Adobe Technology. Customer agrees that when licensing Adobe
    Software for acquisition by the U.S. Government, or any contractor therefore, Customer will license
    consistent with the policies set forth in 48 C.F.R. Section 12.212 (for civilian agencies) and 48 C.F.R.
    Sections 227.7202-1 and 227.7202-4 (for the Department of Defense). For U.S. Government End Users,
    Adobe agrees to comply with all applicable equal opportunity laws including, if appropriate, the
    provisions of Executive Order 11246, as amended, Section 402 of the Vietnam Era Veterans
    Readjustment Assistance Act of 1974 (38 USC 4212), and Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973,
    as amended, and the regulations at 41 CFR Parts 60-1 through 60-60, 60-250, and 60-741. The
    affirmative action clause and regulations contained in the preceding sentence will be incorporated by
    reference into this agreement.

  11. #31

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    17,660
    Real Name
    Have a guess :)

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    12.2 Commercial Items. For U.S. Government End Users, Software is a “Commercial Item(s),” as that
    term is defined at 48 C.F.R. Section 2.101, consisting of “Commercial Computer Software” and
    “Commercial Computer Software Documentation,” as such terms are used in 48 C.F.R. Section 12.212
    or 48 C.F.R. Section 227.7202, as applicable. Consistent with 48 C.F.R. Section 12.212 or 48 C.F.R.
    Sections 227.7202-1 through 227.7202-4, as applicable, the Commercial Computer Software and
    Commercial Computer Software Documentation are being licensed to U.S. Government end users
    (a) only as Commercial Items and (b) with only those rights as are granted to all other end users
    pursuant to the terms and conditions herein. Unpublished-rights reserved under the copyright laws of
    the United States.
    13. Compliance with Licenses.
    If Customer is a business, company, or organization, Customer agrees that, in addition to any license
    compliance checking performed by the Software, Adobe or its authorized representative have the right,
    no more than once every twelve (12) months, upon seven (7) business days’ prior notice to Customer,
    to inspect Customer’s records, systems, and facilities to verify that its use of any and all Adobe software
    or service is in conformity with its valid licenses from Adobe. For example, Adobe has the right to those
    of Customer’s records useful to determine whether installations of the Software have been serialized,
    and Customer shall provide such records to Adobe promptly upon request by Adobe. Additionally,
    Customer shall provide Adobe with all records and information requested by Adobe in order to verify
    that its use of any and all Adobe software is in conformity with its valid licenses from Adobe within
    thirty (30) days of Adobe’s request. Additional information on serialization is available at
    http://www.adobe.com/go/elicensing.
    14. Internet Connectivity and Privacy.
    14.1 Automatic Connections to the Internet. The Software may cause Customer’s Computer, without
    notice, to automatically connect to the Internet and to communicate with an Adobe website or Adobe
    domain for purposes such as license validation and providing Customer with additional information,
    features, or functionality. Unless otherwise specified in Sections 14.2 through 14.7, the following
    provisions apply to all automatic Internet connections by the Software:
    14.1.1 Whenever the Software makes an Internet connection and communicates with an Adobe
    website, whether automatically or due to explicit user request, the Privacy Policy shall apply. Adobe
    Privacy Policy allows tracking of website visits and it addresses in detail the topic of tracking and use of
    cookies, web beacons, and similar devices.
    14.1.2 Whenever the Software connects to Adobe over the Internet, certain Customer information is
    collected and transmitted by the Software to Adobe pursuant to the Adobe Online Privacy Policy
    available at http://www.adobe.com/go/privacy (“Privacy Policy”).
    14.1.3 If Customer accesses an Adobe Online Service (as defined in Section 16.4 below) or activates or
    registers the Software, then additional information such as Customer’s Adobe ID, user name, and
    password may be transmitted to and stored by Adobe pursuant to the Privacy Policy and additional
    terms of use related to such Adobe Online Service (collectively with the Adobe.com terms of use and
    any applicable terms, the “Additional Terms of Use”).
    14.1.4 As permitted by applicable law or as consented to by Customer, Adobe may (a) send Customer
    transactional messages to facilitate the Adobe Online Service or the activation or registration of the
    Software or Adobe Online Service, or (b) deliver in-product marketing to provide information about the
    Software and other Adobe products and Services using information including but not limited to platform
    version, version of the Software, license status, and language.
    14.2 Updating. The Software may cause Customer’s Computer, without additional notice, to
    automatically connect to the Internet (intermittently or on a regular basis) to (a) check for Updates that
    are available for download to and installation on the Computer and (b) notify Adobe of the results of
    installation attempts.
    14.3 Activation. The Software may require Customer to (a) obtain an Adobe ID, (b) activate or reactivate
    the Software, (c) register the software, or (d) validate the Membership. Such requirement may cause
    Customer’s Computer to connect to the Internet without notice on install, on launch, and on a regular
    basis thereafter. Once connected, the Software will collect and transmit information to Adobe as further
    described at http://www.adobe.com/go/activation (“Activation Terms”). Software or Customer may also
    receive information from Adobe related to Customer’s license, subscription, or Membership. Adobe
    may use such information to detect or prevent fraudulent or unauthorized use not in accordance with a
    valid license, subscription, or Membership. Failure to activate or register the Software, validate the
    subscription or Membership, or a determination by Adobe of fraudulent or unauthorized use of the
    Software may result in reduced functionality, inoperability of the Software, or a termination or
    suspension of the subscription or Membership.
    14.4 Deactivation. Customer may deactivate and uninstall the Software from its Computer in order to
    install and activate the Software on another Computer in accordance with this agreement
    (“Deactivation”) and as further described in http://www.adobe.com/go/activation. Deactivation requires
    Internet connectivity.
    14.5 Use of Online Services. The Software may cause Customer’s Computer, without additional notice
    and on an intermittent or regular basis, to automatically connect to the Internet to facilitate Customer’s
    access to content and services that are provided by Adobe or third parties as further described in
    Section 16.4 (Online Services). In addition, the Software may, without additional notice, automatically
    connect to the Internet to update downloadable materials from these online services so as to provide
    immediate availability of these services even when Customer is offline.
    14.6 Digital Certificates. The Software uses digital certificates (as described in Section 16.5) to help
    Customer identify downloaded files (e.g., applications and content) and the publishers of those files. For
    example, Adobe AIR uses digital certificates to help Customer identify the publisher of Adobe AIR
    applications. The Adobe Acrobat family of products also uses digital certificates to sign and validate
    signatures within Portable Document Format (“PDF”) documents and to validate certified PDF
    documents. Customer’s Computer may connect to the Internet at the time of validation of a digital
    certificate.
    14.7 Settings Manager. The Software may include Flash Player. Flash Player may save certain user
    settings by storing them on Customer’s Computer as a local shared object. They are associated with the
    instance of Flash Player on the Computer, allowing Customer to customize runtime features. The Flash
    Player Settings Manager permits Customer to modify such settings, including the ability to limit third
    parties from storing local shared objects or grant third party content the right to access the computer’s
    microphone and camera. Additional information on how to configure settings in its version of Flash
    Player, including information on how to disable local shared objects using the Flash Player Settings
    Manager, is available at http://www.adobe.com/go/settingsmanager. Additional information on local
    shared objects is available at http://www.adobe.com/go/flashplayer_security.
    15. Peer-to-Peer Communications.
    The Software may use Customer’s connection to a local area network, without additional notice, to
    automatically connect to other Adobe software and, in doing so, may indicate on the local area network
    that it is available for communication with other Adobe software. These connections may transmit the
    IP Address of Customer’s connection to the local network.
    16. Specific Provisions and Exceptions.
    This section sets forth specific provisions related to certain products and components of the Software as
    well as limited exceptions to the above terms and conditions. To the extent that any provision in this
    section is in conflict with any other term or condition in this agreement, the terms stated in this section
    will supersede such other term or condition.
    16.1 No Prejudice; European Economic Area Provisions; Australia Mandatory Notice.
    16.1.1 This agreement will not prejudice the statutory rights of any party, including those dealing as
    consumers. For example, for consumers in New Zealand who obtain the Software for personal,
    domestic, or household use (not business purposes), this agreement is subject to the Consumer
    Guarantees Act.
    16.1.2 If Customer obtained the Software in the European Economic Area (EEA), Customer usually
    resides in the EEA and Customer is a consumer (that is its use of the Software is for personal, nonbusiness related purposes), then Section 6 (Limited Warranty) does not apply to Customer’s purchase
    and use of the Software. Instead, Adobe warrants for a period of 2 years from purchase that the Software
    provides the functionalities set forth in the applicable user manual (the “agreed upon functionalities”)
    when used on the Compatible Computer. Non-substantial variation from the agreed upon
    functionalities will not establish any warranty rights. THIS WARRANTY DOES NOT APPLY TO
    SOFTWARE THAT CUSTOMER USES ON A PRE-RELEASE, TRYOUT, STARTER, OR PRODUCT SAMPLER
    BASIS, OR TO FONT SOFTWARE, OR TO THE EXTENT THE SOFTWARE FAILS TO PERFORM BECAUSE IT
    HAS BEEN ALTERED BY CUSTOMER. To make a warranty claim, Customer must notify the Adobe
    Customer Support Department during this 2 year period, providing details of proof of purchase of the
    Software. Adobe will verify with Customer whether there is a defect in the Software or advise Customer
    that the error arises because Customer has not installed the Software correctly (in which case, Adobe
    shall assist Customer). If there is a defect in the Software, Customer may request from Adobe either a
    refund or a repaired or replacement copy of the Software. Requests must be accompanied by proof of
    purchase. In the event Customer’s warranty details are substantiated, Adobe will meet Customer’s
    request for repaired or replacement Software, unless it is not reasonable for Adobe to do so, in which
    case Adobe will provide Customer with a refund. For warranty assistance, please contact the Adobe
    Customer Support Department.
    Please note that the provisions of Section 8 (Limitation of Liability) will continue to apply to any
    damages claims Customer makes in respect of its use of the Software. Nonetheless, Adobe shall be
    liable for direct losses that are reasonably foreseeable in the event of a breach by Adobe of this
    agreement. Customer is advised to take all reasonable measures to avoid and reduce damages, in
    particular by making back-up copies of the Software and its computer data.
    This agreement, and in particular this Section 16.1.2, is intended to describe Customer’s rights (including
    its statutory rights) in the event there should be problems with its use of the Software. If Customer’s
    statutory rights are greater than this description, its statutory rights shall apply.
    16.1.3 Nothing included in this agreement (including Section 4.4) shall limit any non-waivable right to
    decompile the Software that Customer may enjoy under applicable law. For example, if Customer is
    located in the European Union (EU), Customer may have the right upon certain conditions specified in
    the applicable law to decompile the Software if it is necessary to do so in order to achieve
    interoperability of the Software with another software program, and Customer has first asked Adobe in
    writing to provide the information necessary to achieve such operability and Adobe has not made such
    information available. In addition, such decompilation may only be performed by Customer or someone
    else entitled to use a copy of the Software on Customer’s behalf. Adobe has the right to impose
    reasonable conditions before providing such information. Any information supplied by Adobe or
    obtained by Customer, as permitted hereunder, may only be used by Customer for the purpose
    described herein and may not be disclosed to any third party or used to create any software that is
    substantially similar to the expression of the Software or used for any other act that infringes the
    copyright of Adobe or its licensors.
    16.1.4 If Customer obtains the Software in Australia, then the following provision shall apply,
    notwithstanding anything stated to the contrary in this Agreement:
    NOTICE TO CONSUMERS IN AUSTRALIA:
    Our goods come with guarantees that cannot be excluded under the Australian Consumer Law. You are
    entitled to a replacement or refund for a major failure and for compensation for any other reasonably
    foreseeable loss or damage. You are also entitled to have the goods repaired or replaced if the goods
    fail to be of acceptable quality and the failure does not amount to a major failure. Our software products
    also come with a 90-day limited warranty given by Adobe Systems Software Ireland Limited, with an
    office at 4-6 Riverwalk, Citywest Business Campus, Dublin, Ireland, as set out in the Agreement. If your
    products do not provide the general features and functions described in the User Documentation in the
    90-day period after delivery to you, please call the Adobe Customer Support Department at
    1800 614 863 with details of your product, serial number, and proof of purchase. You may be required
    to return the software product to the address we provide to you at the time, in which case such return
    will be at your own cost. The benefits under this warranty are in addition to other rights and remedies
    that you may have at law.


    property of their respective owners.

  12. #32

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    17,660
    Real Name
    Have a guess :)

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    16.2 Pre-release Software Additional Terms. If the Software is pre-commercial release or beta software
    (“Pre-release Software”), then this section applies. The Pre-release Software does not represent final
    product from Adobe, and may contain bugs, errors, and other problems that could cause system or
    other failures and data loss. Adobe may never commercially release the Pre-release Software. If
    Customer received the Pre-release Software pursuant to a separate written agreement, such as the
    Adobe Systems Incorporated License Agreement for Pre-release Software, then Customer’s use of the
    Software is also governed by such agreement. Customer will promptly return or destroy all copies of
    Pre-release Software upon the earlier of Adobe’s request or upon Adobe’s commercial release of such
    Software. CUSTOMER’S USE OF PRE-RELEASE SOFTWARE IS AT ITS OWN RISK. SEE SECTIONS 6 AND 8
    FOR LIMITED WARRANTY AND LIABILITY LIMITATIONS RELATED TO PRE-RELEASE SOFTWARE.
    16.3 Educational Software Product. If the Software is Educational Software Product (Software
    manufactured and distributed for use only by Educational End Users), Customer is not entitled to use
    the Software unless Customer qualify in its jurisdiction as an Educational End User. Please visit
    http://www.adobe.com/go/edu_purchasing to learn about eligibility. Please visit
    http://www.adobe.com/go/store and look for the link for Buying Adobe Products Worldwide to find an
    Adobe Authorized Academic Reseller.
    16.4 Online Services.
    16.4.1 Provided by Adobe. The Software facilitates Customer’s access to content and various services
    that are hosted on websites maintained by Adobe or its affiliates (“Adobe Online Services”). Examples of
    such Adobe Online Services might include, but are not limited to: Adobe BrowserLab, Adobe CS
    Review, Business Catalyst, Digital Publishing Suite, Acrobat.com, Search for Help, and product Welcome
    Screens. In some cases an Adobe Online Service might appear as a feature or extension within the
    Software even though it is hosted on a website. Access to an Adobe Online Service may require
    Customer to activate the Software, obtain an Adobe ID, consent to Additional Terms of Use, or require a
    separate fee in order to access such Adobe Online Services. Adobe Online Services might not be
    available in all languages or to residents of all countries and Adobe may, at any time and for any reason,
    modify or discontinue the availability of any Adobe Online Service. Adobe also reserves the right to
    begin charging a fee for access to or use of an Adobe Online Service that was previously offered at no
    charge. Section 14 states important information regarding Internet connectivity and Customer’s privacy.
    As stated in Section 14, when the Software accesses an Adobe Online Service, Customer’s use of such
    Adobe Online Service is governed by the Adobe Privacy Policy (http://www.adobe.com/go/privacy), by
    the Adobe.com Terms of Use (http://www.adobe.com/go/terms), and by any Additional Terms of Use
    that might be presented to Customer at that time.
    16.4.2 Provided by Third Parties. The Software may facilitate Customer’s access to websites maintained
    by third parties offering goods, information, software, and services (“Third Party Online Services”).
    Examples of such Third Party Online Services might include, but are not limited to, the Kodak EasyShare
    Gallery service. Customer’s access to and use of any Third Party Online Services is governed by the
    terms, conditions, disclaimers, and notices found on such site or otherwise associated with such Third
    Party Online Services. Adobe does not control, endorse, or accept responsibility for Third Party Online
    Services. Any dealings between Customer and any third party in connection with a Third Party Online
    Service, including such party’s privacy policies and use of Customer’s personal information, delivery of
    and payment for goods and services, and any other terms, conditions, warranties, or representations
    associated with such dealings, are solely between Customer and such third party. Third Party Online
    Services might not be available in all languages or to residents of all countries and Adobe may, at any
    time and for any reason, modify or discontinue the availability of any Third Party Online Service.
    16.4.3 EXCEPT AS EXPRESSLY AGREED BY ADOBE OR ITS AFFILIATES OR A THIRD PARTY IN A
    SEPARATE AGREEMENT, CUSTOMER’S USE OF ADOBE ONLINE SERVICES AND THIRD PARTY ONLINE
    SERVICES IS AT ITS OWN RISK UNDER THE WARRANTY AND LIABILITY LIMITATIONS OF SECTIONS 7
    AND 8.
    16.5 Digital Certificates.
    16.5.1 Use. Digital certificates are issued by third party certificate authorities, including Adobe Certified
    Document Services (CDS) vendors listed at http://www.adobe.com/go/partners_cds and Adobe
    Approved Trust List vendors (“AATL”) listed at http://www.adobe.com/go/aatl (collectively “Certificate
    Authorities”), or can be self-signed.
    16.5.2 Terms and Conditions. Purchase, use, and reliance upon digital certificates is the responsibility of
    Customer and a Certificate Authority. Before Customer relies upon any certified document, digital
    signature, or Certificate Authority services, Customer should review the applicable terms and conditions
    under which the relevant Certificate Authority provides services, including, for example, any subscriber
    agreements, relying party agreements, certificate policies, and practice statements. See the links on
    http://www.adobe.com/go/partners_cds for information about Adobe’s CDS vendors and
    http://www.adobe.com/go/aatl for information about AATL vendors.
    16.5.3 Acknowledgement. Customer agrees that (a) the Software, due to configuration or external
    issues, might show a signature as valid despite the fact a digital certificate may have been revoked or
    expired prior to the time of verification; (b) the security or integrity of a digital certificate may be
    compromised due to an act or omission by the signer of the document, the applicable Certificate
    Authority, or any other third party; and (c) a certificate may be a self-signed certificate not provided by a
    Certificate Authority. CUSTOMER IS SOLELY RESPONSIBLE FOR DECIDING WHETHER OR NOT TO RELY
    ON A CERTIFICATE. UNLESS A SEPARATE WRITTEN WARRANTY IS PROVIDED TO CUSTOMER BY A
    CERTIFICATE AUTHORITY, CUSTOMER'S USE OF DIGITAL CERTIFICATES IS AT ITS SOLE RISK.
    16.5.4 Third-Party Beneficiaries. Customer agrees that any Certificate Authority which the Customer
    relies upon is a third-party beneficiary of this agreement and shall have the right to enforce this
    agreement in its own name as if it were Adobe.
    16.5.5 Indemnity. Customer agrees to hold Adobe and any applicable Certificate Authority (except as
    expressly provided in its terms and conditions) harmless from any and all liabilities, losses, actions,
    damages, or claims (including all reasonable expenses, costs, and attorneys’ fees) arising out of or
    relating to Customer’s use of, or any reliance on, any service of such authority, including, without
    limitation: (a) reliance on an expired or revoked certificate; (b) improper verification of a certificate,
    (c) use of a certificate other than as permitted by any applicable terms and conditions, this agreement or
    applicable law; (d) failure to exercise reasonable judgment under the circumstances in relying on issuer
    services or certificates; or (e) failure to perform any of the obligations as required in the terms and
    conditions related to the services.
    16.6 Font Software. If the Software includes font software:
    16.6.1 Customer may use the font software with the Software on Computers as described in Section 2
    and output the font software to any output device(s) connected to such Computer(s).
    16.6.2 If the Permitted Number of Computers is five (5) or fewer, Customer may download the font
    software to the memory (hard disk or RAM) of one output device connected to at least one of such
    Computers for the purpose of having the font software remain resident in such output device, and of
    one more such output device for every multiple of five represented by the Permitted Number of
    Computers.
    16.6.3 Customer may take a copy of the font(s) Customer has used for a particular file to a commercial
    printer or other service bureau, and such service bureau may use the font(s) to process its file, provided
    such service bureau has a valid license to use that particular font software.
    16.6.4 Customer may embed copies of the font software into its electronic documents for the purpose of
    printing, viewing, and editing the document. No other embedding rights are implied or permitted under
    this license.
    16.6.5 As an exception to the above, the fonts listed at http://www.adobe.com/go/restricted_fonts are
    included with the Software only for purposes of operation of the Software user interface and not for
    inclusion within any Output Files. Such listed fonts are not licensed under this Section 16.6. Customer
    agrees that it will not copy, move, activate or use, or allow any font management tool to copy, move,
    activate or use, such listed fonts in or with any software application, program, or file other than the
    Software.
    16.7 After Effects Render Engine. If the Software includes the full version of Adobe After Effects, then
    Customer may install an unlimited number of Render Engines on Computers within its Internal Network
    which includes at least one Computer on which the full version of the Adobe After Effects software is
    installed. The term “Render Engine” means an installable portion of the Software that allows After
    Effects projects to be rendered but which cannot be used to create or modify projects and does not
    include the complete After Effects user interface.
    16.8 Acrobat Standard, Acrobat Pro, and Adobe Acrobat Suite Features. If the Software includes Acrobat
    Standard, Acrobat Pro, Acrobat Suite, or certain features within the above software, then this
    Section 16.8 shall apply.
    16.8.1 Additional Definitions.
    16.8.1.1 “Deploy” means to deliver or otherwise make available, directly or indirectly, by any means
    including but not limited to a network or Internet, an Extended Document to one or more recipients.
    16.8.1.2 “Extended Document” means a PDF file manipulated by the Software to enable the ability to
    locally save documents with filled-in PDF forms.
    16.8.2 The Software may include enabling technology that allows Customer to enable PDF documents
    with certain features through the use of a digital credential located within the Software (“Key”).
    Customer agrees not to access, attempt to access, control, disable, remove, use, or distribute the Key for
    any purpose.
    16.8.3 For any unique Extended Document Customer may only either (a) Deploy such Extended
    Document to an unlimited number of unique recipients, but Customer shall not extract information or
    cause the information to be extracted from more than five hundred (500) unique instances of such
    Extended Document or any hardcopy representation of such Extended Document containing filled form
    fields; or (b) Deploy such Extended Document to no more than five hundred (500) unique recipients
    without limits on the number of times Customer may extract information from such Extended
    Document returned to Customer filled-in by such recipients. Notwithstanding anything herein to the
    contrary, obtaining additional licenses to use Acrobat Standard, Acrobat Pro, or Adobe Acrobat Suite
    shall not increase the foregoing limits (that is, the foregoing limits are the aggregate total limits
    regardless of how many additional licenses to use Acrobat Standard, Acrobat Pro, or Adobe Acrobat
    Suite Customer may have obtained).
    16.9 Flash Player Projectors and Runtime. Customer’s rights to use any Flash player, projector,
    standalone player, plug-in, runtime, or ActiveX control provided to Customer as part of or with the
    Software, or in an Output File shall be governed by terms available at
    http://www.adobe.com/go/flashplayer_usage. Unless and except as provided therein, Customer shall
    have no rights to use or distribute such software.
    16.10 Contribute Publishing Services. Subject to the Contribute Publishing Services software end user
    license agreement accompanying such software, Customer shall not connect to the Contribute
    Publishing Services software unless Customer has purchased a license to connect to such Contribute
    Publishing Services software for each individual who may connect to such Contribute Publishing
    Services software; provided, however, that trial versions of Adobe Contribute software may install and
    connect to the Contribute Publishing Services software in accordance with the Contribute Publishing
    Services software end user license agreement.
    16.11 Adobe Presenter. If the Software includes Adobe Presenter and Customer installs or uses the
    Adobe Connect Add-in in connection with the use of the Software, Customer agrees that it will install
    and use such add-in only on a desktop Computer and not on any non-PC product, including, but not
    limited to, a web appliance, set top box, handheld, phone, or web pad device. Further, the portion of the
    Software that is embedded in a presentation, information, or content created and generated using the
    Software (the “Adobe Presenter Run-Time”) may only be used together with the presentation,
    information, or content in which it is embedded. Customer shall not use, and shall cause all licensees of
    such presentation, information, or content not to use, the Adobe Presenter Run-Time other than as
    embedded in such presentation, information or content. In addition, Customer shall not use, and shall
    cause all licensees of such presentation, information, or content not to, modify, reverse engineer, or
    disassemble the Adobe Presenter Run-Time.
    16.12 Flash Builder with LiveCycle Data Services (LCDS) Data Management Library. Adobe Flash Builder
    may include the fds.swc library. Customer may use fds.swc only to provide client-side data management
    capabilities and as an output file within software Customer develops, subject to the following: Customer
    may not (a) use fds.swc to enable associations or offline capabilities within software or (b) incorporate
    fds.swc into any software that is similar to Adobe LiveCycle Data Services or BlazeDS. If Customer would
    like to do any of the foregoing, Customer will need to request a separate license from Adobe.
    16.13 Digital Publishing Suite. The following terms apply if Software includes certain components or
    features designed to work with or access Digital Publishing Suite, subject to the Additional Terms of Use
    for Digital Publishing Suite. “DPS Desktop Tools” means Folio Overlays Panel, Folio Builder Panel,
    Content Viewer for Desktop, and Digital Publishing Plug-in for InDesign. If the Software includes DPS
    Desktop Tool (or any component thereof), then, except as otherwise provided in this Section 16 or the
    Additional Terms of Use, Customer may install and use the DPS Desktop Tools solely for the purposes of
    (a) creating or producing the content designed to be displayed within the Content Viewer (“Output”),
    (b) evaluating and testing the Output, and (c) where available, accessing and using the Adobe Digital
    Publishing Suite services pursuant to the Additional Terms of Use. Except as otherwise permitted herein,
    Customer may not display, distribute, modify, or publicly perform the DPS Desktop Tools.
    16.14 AVC DISTRIBUTION. The following notice applies to Software containing AVC import and export
    functionality: THIS PRODUCT IS LICENSED UNDER THE AVC PATENT PORTFOLIO LICENSE FOR THE
    PERSONAL NON-COMMERCIAL USE OF A CONSUMER TO (a) ENCODE VIDEO IN COMPLIANCE WITH
    THE AVC STANDARD (“AVC VIDEO”) AND/OR (b) DECODE AVC VIDEO THAT WAS ENCODED BY A
    CONSUMER ENGAGED IN A PERSONAL NON-COMMERCIAL ACTIVITY AND/OR WAS OBTAINED
    FROM A VIDEO PROVIDER LICENSED TO PROVIDE AVC VIDEO. NO LICENSE IS GRANTED OR SHALL
    BE IMPLIED FOR ANY OTHER USE. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION MAY BE OBTAINED FROM MPEG LA,
    L.L.C. SEE http://www.adobe.com/go/mpegla.
    16.15 MPEG-2 DISTRIBUTION. The following notice applies to Software containing MPEG-2 import and
    export functionality: USE OF THIS PRODUCT OTHER THAN CONSUMER PERSONAL USE IN ANY
    MANNER THAT COMPLIES WITH THE MPEG-2 STANDARD FOR ENCODING VIDEO INFORMATION FOR
    PACKAGED MEDIA IS EXPRESSLY PROHIBITED WITHOUT A LICENSE UNDER APPLICABLE PATENTS IN
    THE MPEG-2 PATENT PORTFOLIO, WHICH LICENSE IS AVAILABLE FROM MPEG LA, L.L.C. 250 STEELE
    STREET, SUITE 300 DENVER, COLORADO 80206.
    16.16 Apple. If the Software is downloaded from the Apple iTunes Application Store (“App”), then
    Customer acknowledges and agrees to the following additional terms: (a) Apple has no liability for the
    App and its content; (b) Customer’s use of the App is limited to a non-transferable license to use the
    App on any iPhone™, iPad™ or iPod Touch™ that Customer owns or controls as allowed by the Application
    Store Terms of Service; (c) Apple has no obligation whatsoever to furnish any maintenance and support
    services for the App; (d) to the extent permitted by applicable law, Apple has no warranty obligation to
    the App and Adobe will be responsible for any claims, losses, liabilities, damages, costs, or expenses
    attributable to any failure to conform to any warranty set forth in this Agreement; (e) Apple is not liable
    for any claims relating to the App or Customer’s possession and/or use of the App, including, but not
    limited to: (i) product liability claims; (ii) any claim that the App fails to conform to any applicable legal
    requirement; and (iii) consumer protection claims; (f) Apple is not liable for any third-party claims that
    the App infringes a third party’s intellectual property rights; and (g) Apple and its subsidiaries are third
    party beneficiaries of this Agreement with respect to any such App, and that Apple will have the right to
    enforce the Agreement against Customer as a third party beneficiary.
    If you have any questions regarding this agreement or if you wish to request any information from
    Adobe, please use the address and contact information included with this product to contact the Adobe
    office serving your jurisdiction.
    The name of this Software, Adobe, Acrobat, Adobe Connect, AIR, After Effects, Authorware, Business
    Catalyst, Contribute, Creative Suite, Digital Publishing Suite, Flash, Flash Builder, LiveCycle, Pixel Bender,
    Presenter, Shockwave, and all related titles and logos are either registered trademarks or trademarks of
    Adobe Systems Incorporated in the United States and/or other countries. All other trademarks are the

  13. #33

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    17,660
    Real Name
    Have a guess :)

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    And that was just ONE EULA for ONE of the products we use daily!

  14. #34
    Shadowman's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    WNY
    Posts
    36,716
    Real Name
    John

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    Quote Originally Posted by DeepWater View Post
    Some questions from a non Facebook user
    Pardon my ignorance but it would seem to me that the way to circumvent the issue is to use Facebook as social network tool but have it link to your images on another site, such as SmugMug. Then there is nothing for them to steal, and to me what they are doing is theft, pure, plain and simple. As has been pointed out they are integrated into everything so to quit using them if they are beneficial might not be the way to go. I have intentionally avoided all the social media hype for years so I am not really knowledgeable in this area, but am looking into marketing my services now and the social media is where everyone is at, so it seems. Thus my thoughts about using them but not having pictures posted. Am I wet behind the ears?? What do you think? There has to be a way to beat them at their own game.
    Also, don't provide a high quality image that can be easily downloaded for free.

  15. #35

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    17,660
    Real Name
    Have a guess :)

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    Quote Originally Posted by DeepWater View Post
    Some questions from a non Facebook user
    Pardon my ignorance but it would seem to me that the way to circumvent the issue is to use Facebook as social network tool but have it link to your images on another site, such as SmugMug.
    There really isn't any "issue" that needs circumventing, but none-the-less, you may be interested to read a snip of SmugMugs T&C:

    You retain the copyright in any User Content you post on the Site. SmugMug neither has nor wants any ownership of your Content. However, by uploading and/or posting any User Content to the Site, you grant SmugMug a perpetual, nonexclusive and royalty-free right to use the User Content and the name that is submitted in connection with such User Content, as is reasonably necessary to display the User Content, provide the Services and to facilitate, at Content Owner's direction, the license of Photos or the sale of Products on the Site.


    Then there is nothing for them to steal, and to me what they are doing is theft, pure, plain and simple.
    They're not stealing anything.

    As has been pointed out they are integrated into everything so to quit using them if they are beneficial might not be the way to go. I have intentionally avoided all the social media hype for years so I am not really knowledgeable in this area, but am looking into marketing my services now and the social media is where everyone is at, so it seems. Thus my thoughts about using them but not having pictures posted. Am I wet behind the ears?? What do you think?
    I think folks need to take a step back and stop giving the sh*t-stirring publications the attention they're getting with their grand-standing. If these services are good enough for practically ALL of the world's top photographers (who make a zillion times more than I ever will), then it's good enough for me.


    There has to be a way to beat them at their own game.
    James, they're not "the enemy" - they're a business who has to try and make money from a valuable product that they give away for free - and in a nutshell that requires targeted advertising. It's not realistic to expect a free service without the end user being asked to "give a little back". They're not stealing anything - they're not being sneaky about anything - they're simply saying that if you want to use our free services then you need to let us use thumbnail-sized copies of a tiny fraction of the users stored image base to assist with targeted advertising.

    Having advertised on Facebook I think folks will find that additional demographics such as age / sex / location / interests will be worth a zillion times more to them as advertising tools than the photos.

  16. #36

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    17,660
    Real Name
    Have a guess :)

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    Blog entry from Instagram's co-founder:

    http://blog.instagram.com/post/38421...-your-feedback

    I especially liked the bit "You also had deep concerns about whether under our new terms, Instagram had any plans to sell your content. I want to be really clear: Instagram has no intention of selling your photos, and we never did. We don’t own your photos – you do."

  17. #37

    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Provence, France
    Posts
    991
    Real Name
    Remco

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    @Colin:
    There's at least one big difference between the license users grant smugmug, compared to the license for Facebook/Instagram:
    for smugmug, the license is limited to what is needed for the service they provide, not quite what FB/instagram wants as rights.

    and your last quote considers current situation and past situation, nothing about the future, and the new ToS aren't in effect yet...
    As instagram is now part of facebook, how much clout does the con-founder still have?

    Finally, I never thought I'd have to say this, but I find your posting of FOUR maximum-sized posts offensive, especially for a forum
    administrator. (such an integral copy and publication might be a copyright violation?)

  18. #38

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    17,660
    Real Name
    Have a guess :)

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    Quote Originally Posted by revi View Post
    @Colin:
    There's at least one big difference between the license users grant smugmug, compared to the license for Facebook/Instagram:
    for smugmug, the license is limited to what is needed for the service they provide, not quite what FB/instagram wants as rights.
    Maybe ... but what it SAYS is "as is reasonably necessary" ... and I'll bet that in the event of a dispute then their definition of "reasonably necessary" would be different to the other parties definition.That's not the point though ... the point is that no matter what T&C / EULA you read you're going to find things that can be taken one way when that way was never intended. The Instagram thing was a perfect example of this - never once did they ever have the slightest intention of selling users photos (just stop and think of the absurdity of the thought of that for just a moment) -- I'm pretty sure the folks who turned the mountain into a molehill probably knew that too - and yet millions of "sheeple" got on their "high-horses" - "totally outraged" etc. Do people just believe everything they read on the internet these days without stopping to actually think for themselves?

    and your last quote considers current situation and past situation, nothing about the future, and the new ToS aren't in effect yet...
    As instagram is now part of facebook, how much clout does the con-founder still have?
    *bangs head against wall*. Trust me - they're not going to be selling users photos. Why? Because it would be commercial suicide and they're not stupid enough to commit commercial suicide.

    Finally, I never thought I'd have to say this, but I find your posting of FOUR maximum-sized posts offensive, especially for a forum
    administrator. (such an integral copy and publication might be a copyright violation?)
    Why is it "offensive"? - if you don't want to read it (and I assume that most wouldn't) - then spend 2 seconds rolling your mouse wheel to scroll past it.

  19. #39

    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand
    Posts
    17,660
    Real Name
    Have a guess :)

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    Quote Originally Posted by revi View Post
    @Colin:
    There's at least one big difference between the license users grant smugmug, compared to the license for Facebook/Instagram:
    for smugmug, the license is limited to what is needed for the service they provide, not quite what FB/instagram wants as rights.
    Maybe ... but what it SAYS is "as is reasonably necessary" ... and I'll bet that in the event of a dispute then their definition of "reasonably necessary" would be different to the other parties definition.That's not the point though ... the point is that no matter what T&C / EULA you read you're going to find things that can be taken one way when that way was never intended. The Instagram thing was a perfect example of this - never once did they ever have the slightest intention of selling users photos (just stop and think of the absurdity of the thought of that for just a moment) -- I'm pretty sure the folks who turned the mountain into a molehill probably knew that too - and yet millions of "sheeple" got on their "high-horses" - "totally outraged" etc. Do people just believe everything they read on the internet these days without stopping to actually think for themselves? Apparently not!

    and your last quote considers current situation and past situation, nothing about the future, and the new ToS aren't in effect yet...
    As instagram is now part of facebook, how much clout does the con-founder still have?
    *bangs head against wall*. Trust me - they're not going to be selling users photos. Why? Because it would be commercial suicide and they're not stupid enough to commit commercial suicide.

    Finally, I never thought I'd have to say this, but I find your posting of FOUR maximum-sized posts offensive, especially for a forum
    administrator. (such an integral copy and publication might be a copyright violation?)
    Why is it "offensive"? - if you don't want to read it (and I assume that most wouldn't) - then spend 2 seconds rolling your mouse wheel to scroll past it.

  20. #40

    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    Provence, France
    Posts
    991
    Real Name
    Remco

    Re: Facebook/Instagram wants to sell your photos with no compensation to you?

    Quote Originally Posted by Colin Southern View Post
    Maybe ... but what it SAYS is "as is reasonably necessary" ... and I'll bet that in the event of a dispute then their definition of "reasonably necessary" would be different to the other parties definition.That's not the point though ... the point is that no matter what T&C / EULA you read you're going to find things that can be taken one way when that way was never intended. The Instagram thing was a perfect example of this - never once did they ever have the slightest intention of selling users photos (just stop and think of the absurdity of the thought of that for just a moment) -- I'm pretty sure the folks who turned the mountain into a molehill probably knew that too - and yet millions of "sheeple" got on their "high-horses" - "totally outraged" etc. Do people just believe everything they read on the internet these days without stopping to actually think for themselves?

    *bangs head against wall*. Trust me - they're not going to be selling users photos. Why? Because it would be commercial suicide and they're not stupid enough to commit commercial suicide.
    Ok, lets postulate for now that they cannot sell users' photos without committing 'commercial suicide'*. Do they know that, and if they do,
    why do they insist on having such a broad clause?

    The clause from smugmug has at least a limitation to uses related to smugmug, the facebook clause doesn't have such a limitation.

    *) I'm not convinced that it would be commercial suicide, as all the noise about this and other privacy concerns doesn't seem to have had much effect. I'm not even sure that more than 5% of the users knows what is going on.

    An exemple of why I don't like such a broad clause: a rather extremist political party in NZ (views opposite to yours) likes your photo of the bridge, and offers to license it from facebook. They get it and post it with your name under it... You gave a license to sub-license the photo w/o limitation, and no release needed, as no recognisable persons on it. But now your name is linked to that party.

    Why is it "offensive"? - if you don't want to read it (and I assume that most wouldn't) - then spend 2 seconds rolling your mouse wheel to scroll past it.
    Spam?

Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •