Histogram - Long, flat and wide

[Mike Buckley]

For this particular image, I would've liked the ducks to stand out more from the water (pop)... If I used a faster shutter speed the image would have been too dark. (iso 800 is high for my camera). If I upped the exposure comp the water would've been overexposed, and I shot as wide open as I could.

There are a couple of issues, Christina. You could have maintained the desired ISO and used a faster shutter speed by using a larger aperture, so long of course that you would have still maintained the desired depth of field and assuming that a larger aperture was available.

However, using a faster shutter speed would not have separated the ducks from the water. This image reminds me of shooting an image through frosted glass. The only way to get greater separation between the frosted glass and the subject is to remove the glass. In your case, the bright water is similarly between the camera and the ducks. Our eye tends to see bright objects first, so the only way to truly make the ducks stand out is to shoot them without the water or with significantly less water. The moral of the story is that it's inadvisable to try to make something of a scene that can't be made.

And in the case of photographing in low contrast situations, ie; foggy days, could I not change the tone curve in my camera to a high contrast curve to fix it right then and there?

Again, it's generally best in my mind not to try making something of a scene that isn't there unless you are being really creative, such as the images that Sharon regularly makes that bear little resemblance to the physical scene. If you want a high-contrast image, shoot a high-contrast scene or at least a medium-contrast scene. If the scene is gorgeous and has little contrast, exploit that characteristic to your advantage rather than eliminate it.

I was under the impression, that the understanding the histogram, beyond its use for exposure compensation could be useful for other photographic parameters/variables but perhaps not?

As Dave pointed out, the histogram can be used for things other than exposure compensation, though like any tool it has its limitations.

Sorry that I can't address your other questions. I'm interested in seeing other responses to all of your concerns.

[Brownbear]

Mike, as always, thank you Mike.. 5.6 is as wide open as I can shoot with my long lens (Tamron 200-400)

Good to know

My question has been answered very thoroughly. I'm good to go...