Hang In There - Compositon

[matman4u]

I am struggling with the composition of this... Which composition do you think works best?
Thanks,
Matt

#1

#2

#3

[tamccain]

For me, I like #1 the best

[deetheturk]

No 1 for me to.

[Dave Humphries]

Which composition do you think works best?

How about this one?



Perhaps with a bit more below.



Cute fella,

[FootLoose]

No 1 appeals to me, Matt, but the final decision depends on what you want this picture to be: a frog on a leaf, or a leaf with a frog on it.

[Brownbear]

3 and Dave's 2nd version

[matman4u]

No 1 appeals to me, Matt, but the final decision depends on what you want this picture to be: a frog on a leaf, or a leaf with a frog on it.

Thank you all for your feedback.
Greg, you expressed my dilemma better than I could.... I feel that I should include the leaf for color and to give the setting/perspective. But the frog is clearly the star of the photos.

That is why I was interested in what others would do.

[matman4u]

How about this one?

Thank you Dave

[jstp]

Hey Matt,

I find the first one the best of the ones you have provided, the other ones the stem takes away from the frog for me.

Cheers

J

[Shadowman]

I like the composition of the first, however my eyes favor the 2nd and 3rd image for perceived detail. Second image more so than the third.

[matman4u]

Thank you. I appreciate the input.
I have adjusted the color of #1 a little.
What do you think?



Matt