Originally Posted by
Mike Buckley
Thank you, everyone!
When I add a vignette especially in a landscape scene, it's usually one that isn't noticed unless it is removed, sort of like food seasoning that you don't notice unless the dish is served without it. In this image, the vignette is strong enough that it is immediately noticeable.
Perhaps of interest only to a photographer, the vignette in one of the top corners was created by the lighting and the other one was created during post-processing. I would be willing to bet that nobody would assuredly know which corner was changed during post-processing.
Perhaps it's just a matter of semantics, but I don't think of the vignette as keeping the viewer's eye from straying as much as making sure that the brighter parts are allowed to lead the viewer's eye to where I want it to go.
It wasn't so much the tone of that shadow that concerned me as was its softness, so I used a relatively large light source.
It was also important to me that the neck and spout would cast at least a slight shadow. Ironically, if the porron had been made of really high quality, perfectly clear glass, far less shadow would have been created. The glass happens to be very green, so I decided to make that color and the darker shadow that it produces attractive aspects of the image.
The lamp that created the shadow also lit the tabletop. While dealing with that lamp, the tone and texture of the brighter areas of the tabletop were far more important to me than the tone of the shadow. I wanted a very slight texture to be displayed in the tabletop, not one that you would necessarily notice but one that you would miss if it was removed (note that recurring theme). I also wanted the tabletop to be slightly darker than the background but not so much darker that it would create a strong horizon. Once those two objectives were achieved, I was happy to let the tone of the shadow fall pretty much as it may.
Speaking of shadows, the shadow on the cork was created by a separate light source, a speed light. I wanted that shadow's tone to be dark enough to indicate the shape of the cork but light enough to reveal at least a little bit of detail in the surface of the cork, which is admittedly difficult to see in the small size displayed here.
I gave no conscious thought to that. It might simply be that I'm right-handed and lifted the porron's handle with that hand, which naturally pointed the spout to the left. If the glass had not produced attractive dark tones in this position, I suppose I would have tried changing the direction of the spout. I liked the tones that were produced so much in this orientation that I didn't even try the other orientation.