Looks like you got it right sharp and more like what it looked like. I haven't CS4 so can't do that well and I can't tell from the camera histogram where it looks blown on the right if it is actually blown until I get home. Sometimes you can just reduce ev and get definition back and it wasn't blown at all. That is why you got the wrong one because I took a lot just in case of camera shake so that I could choose the best trio, and I was looking at a different middle image where reducing ev by one stop brought back definition.
You got the best one in the end and I used GG2 filter on it. cheers