I like the tighter crop.
I prefer the second image, Brian.
In the first one there is a foreground insect which has a blurred face (bottom left corner) and for me this spoils what would otherwise be an excellent photo. I don't mind something blurred in the background but it usually looks odd when in the foreground.
This makes for a better grouping in the second shot. Although this one could be cropped slightly closer if you wanted to make it more like #1.