Originally Posted by
Dave Humphries
I agree, #3 is my favourite too, but then it's at an angle you can't usually get (at least not without getting into trouble) and I like railways. A nice bit of straight line with an excellent vanishing point and symmetry, well done.
For my personal taste, #1 has a bit too much black clipped foreground, a crop of 15% off the bottom would suit me.
#2 sort of works, but I can't help feeling it isn;t the ideal arrangement of sun angle and clouds. Also, the basic composition might benefit from another 10% extra on the left hand side, the brightly lit horizontal rails are just too near the corner.
Cheers,