DSLR vs non-DSLR- can you see the difference?

[dem]

That's easy:
#A is p&s (4:3 aspect ratio)
#B is DSLR (3:2 aspect ratio)

[ajohnw]

Thanks for putting in your guesses folks! The two cameras I used were Fujifilm SL1000, superzoom, and Nikon D7100 w/ 18-55 mm lens. SOme of your guesses were right, and some weren't, but I agree it's hard to tell!

The photos originated from each camera as follows:

D7100 images:

#1, evergreen, 1/100, f/11, iso 500

#2, Beaver stump, 1/50, f/11, ISO, 2200

#4, rabbit, 1/60, f/ 6.3, ISO, 200, on-camera flash



Fuji SL1000 images,

#3, rabbit, 1/100, F/4.8, ISO, 100

#5, leaf, 1/500, f/2.9, ISO, 100

I got about 65% correct guesses, I think, the, way I interpreted them, ( assuming Haseeb meant 2&4 are DSLR).

It wasn't my main point to compare the quality of the two cameras, but I suppose it does indicate that if you only shoot things the camera can handle, (enough light etc.) and use them on a screen this size or smaller, and do some editing of the photos, and use only ones that turned out well,the difference is not significant - though some of you could pick out some of them. Not everyone probably needs a DSLR even if they want great quality photos, though some probably do!

I didn't include long telephoto shots with the superzoom, because I didn't have any long telephoto shots with the DSLR. As for those, such as bird images, I think it would have been easier to discern which were which. I have a FEW bird shots that would be hard to tell from good DSLR bird shots, but far fewer of those than easier subjects especially those at a shorter. range than regular range.

I did wonder about 3 because the eye is odd. Got 5 right because they "invent" detail when they have problems. That's why the bulb looks a bit odd in the one I posted - it "invented" the rest but had trouble with that.

John
-

[HaseebM]

Thanks for putting in your guesses folks! The two cameras I used were Fujifilm SL1000, superzoom, and Nikon D7100 w/ 18-55 mm lens. SOme of your guesses were right, and some weren't, but I agree it's hard to tell!

The photos originated from each camera as follows:

D7100 images:

#1, evergreen, 1/100, f/11, iso 500

#2, Beaver stump, 1/50, f/11, ISO, 2200

#4, rabbit, 1/60, f/ 6.3, ISO, 200, on-camera flash



Fuji SL1000 images,

#3, rabbit, 1/100, F/4.8, ISO, 100

#5, leaf, 1/500, f/2.9, ISO, 100

I got about 65% correct guesses, I think, the, way I interpreted them, ( assuming Haseeb meant 2&4 are DSLR).

It wasn't my main point to compare the quality of the two cameras, but I suppose it does indicate that if you only shoot things the camera can handle, (enough light etc.) and use them on a screen this size or smaller, and do some editing of the photos, and use only ones that turned out well,the difference is not significant - though some of you could pick out some of them. Not everyone probably needs a DSLR even if they want great quality photos, though some probably do!

I didn't include long telephoto shots with the superzoom, because I didn't have any long telephoto shots with the DSLR. As for those, such as bird images, I think it would have been easier to discern which were which. I have a FEW bird shots that would be hard to tell from good DSLR bird shots, but far fewer of those than easier subjects especially those at a shorter. range than regular range.

Yes I meant 2 & 4 were DSLR. I didn't check anything except allow my eyes to guess.

[Nicks Pics]

Thanks guys!

That's easy:
#A is p&s (4:3 aspect ratio)
#B is DSLR (3:2 aspect ratio)

Actually I cropped all of them so that whatever aspect ratio they are now doesn't really indicate what they were. I used mostly neither 2x3 or 4x3, but actually looking back there may be one 4x3, but it's not a P&S one.

[dem]

Thanks guys!




Actually I cropped all of them so that whatever aspect ratio they are now doesn't really indicate what they were. I used mostly neither 2x3 or 4x3, but actually looking back there may be one 4x3, but it's not a P&S one.

I know. You also numbered your images from 1 to 5 and then GeoBonsai posted two images #A and #B.