Minimal Beach. C&C would be appreciated

[bambleweeney]

I like the lines and the colour in this one, then five minutes later I look at it again and I'm just not sure anymore. Opinions/suggestions greatly appreciated ...

[andrewaxford]

Hi Paul
I would consider cropping the sea out all together and focus the attention more on the curved sand bar.

[pnodrog]

Andrew 100% I see a variety of cropping options none of them include the sea.

You called it minimal so go for it..

[joebranko]

Hi Paul,
I agree with the previous comments; I would crop the sea as it does not really add to the pic. Also there is something in the bottom left corner I would consider loosing, either by cropping or, if you want to keep the ripples in the sand, by morphing it out. Just my opinion and I am far from expert.

[Shadowman]

Nice effort, without the water scene could be interpreted many ways.

[IzzieK]

I totally and completely agree with all three comments above.

[Geoff F]

So we are all in agreement here.

If it was the other way around, with that bit of sea at the bottom, I think it might work; but this way around the scene seems to be 'top heavy'