Quote Originally Posted by Downrigger View Post
On the vignette - I tend to add enough how the image feels without affecting how it looks i.e. add 'til you notice it. Which would be somewhere between the original you posted and the one without it. This is an image where I also might experiment with reversing it. It is such a lovely image some experimentation is called for, and I think something other than none might be your favorite.
I agree with Mark. Your final effort is on the mark. (definitely no pun intended Mark).