Originally Posted by
Donald
Colin
Taking the two together and, for ease, referring to them as #1 and #2 (as I think they provide a good opportunity for a compare and contrast exercise) ..........
#1#2
In #1 the building and, of course, its reflection provide a good strong line taking us into the frame. The river in #2 provides that, but, in my opinion, not as strongly.
I like the composition and framing of #1. There's interest in all parts of the frame. And although we have the reflection of the tower/fortress (?) coming to the bottom of teh frame in #2, I feel there's an awful lot of 'dead' space where there's nothing much happening so far as the water is concerned.
I see there is, I think, a bird on the walkway just in the sunlight in #2. I wonder if that would have been a much better location for this shot than the bridge which you are standing on.
That's one person's thoughts. There will be others no doubt. And remember, they are only my thoughts and can be dismissed as readily as they can be accepted.