![Quote](images/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
William W
OK, I understand. I run you through a few points that should form a basis for your experiments.
*
Good. That’s important for you to understand. You should see why it is so important in, a few minutes.
*
OK. Thank you.
Couple of minor points:
1. “speedlite is a cheap knockoff (Allura) – TYPO? “Altura Photo” ?
2. “moved to shooting 3.5 at 4000 in order to have an increased focal range.” – assume you mean increased DoF (Depth of Field)?
*
For the sake of this conversation we need to assume a “typical” exposure that you use for the AMBIENT LIGHT.
From the information you have provided we will assume that you are pulling the shot at:
F/2.8 @ 1/640s @ ISO3200.
***
Consideration of using the Flash that you have (Altura), without and with a “Beamer” on its head.
You do NOT have HSS available.
You need to FREEZE the SUBJECT MOTION by using the FLASH EXPOSURE. To do this you will need to have the FLASH as the KEY exposure. This means the FLASH Exposure MUST be greater than the AMBIENT Exposure. Remember this point.
Also (in simple terms) the faster the SPEED of the Subject Movement, then the greater the DIFFERENCE between the FLASH Exposure and the Ambient Exposure is required. Remember this point too.
Data attained from the User Manual (Altura_Photo_Flash-CANON_USER_GUIDE)
Guide Number for your Flash Unit: GN = 68 (Meters)ISO100 @ FL 105mm
This Guide Number is the key to this discussion and to discovering what might or might not be possible. The Guide Number is a GUIDE. (Note: also sometimes Manufactures will ‘embellish’). The Guide Number above is when the Flash Head is fully zoomed in to cover only the FoV of a 105mm lens on a (135 format) Camera. If you are using a Wide Angle Lens or a Normal Lens and the Flash Head is zoomed wide to cover that FoV, then the Guide Number will be a lower number.
At this point the light globe might have gone and the man in your head is saying “OK now I get how the beamer works, it is just adding more ‘zoom in’ to the Flash Head so therefore the GN will get bigger . . .” . . . yes that’s how it works – and that’s why you might get an “hot spot” – for example, if you Flash head is zoomed to cover the FoV of a 400mm lens’s and you only have a 200mm Lens mounted on your camera - what you want in this situation is for the hot spot to be in the centre of the frame and your player to be in that hot spot.
The Guide Number divided by the APERTURE used will give you the MAXIMUM FLASH WORKING DISTANCE. So: GN/A = MFWD.
Note the Guide Number (68Meters) is for ISO 100. As you increase the ISO the Guide Number gets bigger by a factor of √2 for each Stop of ISO, or more simply the Guide Number doubles for each 2 STOPS of ISO increase. If you are adept at mental arithmetic, √2 is about 1.4.
*
Now back to the two points I asked you to remember:
> Flash Exposure has to be KEY over Ambient Exposure
> Faster Subject Movement ≡ bigger difference between Flash Exposure and Ambient Exposure
You can experiment and find the correct answers - I’ll make experienced guesses to put you in the ballpark:
I reckon the Flash Exposure will need to be FOUR STOPS over the Ambient Exposure as your starting point for the Flash to Freeze the SUBJECT MOVEMENT of the speed of typical Ice Hockey Play.
With that as our starting point let’s look at your Ambient Exposure:
F/2.8 @ 1/640s @ ISO3200 ≡ F/2.8 @ 1/320s @ ISO1600 ≡ F/2.8 @ 1/250s @ ISO 1250
BUT – we need Flash Exposure to be FOUR STOPS over the Ambient Exposure.
Therefore we need to DROP (underexpose) Ambient by FOUR STOPS.
Hence: [F/2.8 @ 1/250s @ ISO 1250] – [4 Stops] ≡ F/11 @ 1/250s @ ISO 1250 ≡ F/10 @ 1/250s @ ISO 1600
So now let’s look at the Flash’s GN for ISO 1600:
100 > 200 > 400 > 800 > 1600
ISO 100 to ISO 1600 4 Stops, therefore we can multiply the GN (for ISO100) by 4
Hence: 68 x 4 = 272
So we can now work out how far you can shoot:
272/10 ≈ 27
*
Summary using Flash without Beamer:
> Without any “beamer” you can use you Flash “naked”, and you’ll have a MAXIMUM FLASH WORKING DISTANCE of about 27metres (about 90 ft) at ISO 1600.
> To do this you would pull the shot at: F/10 @ 1/250s @ ISO1600
> That cribs you one stop of ISO and less noise.
> In a nutshell you’re stuffed for any play beyond 90ft
> AND you HAVE TO WAIT FOR THE FLASH TO RECYCLE BEFORE YOU CAN SHOOT AGAIN (isn’t this last point gut wrenching! ?)
> We can extrapolate at ISO 3200 the GN would be about 380 (i.e. 272 x 1.4) And: 380/10 = 38, therefore without any “beamer” you can use you Flash “naked”, and you’ll have a MAXIMUM FLASH WORKING DISTANCE of about 38metres (about 125 ft) at ISO 3200, and to do this you would pull the shot at: F/10 @ 1/250s @ ISO3200
NOTES -
The above ballpark theory assumes the following:
> The Manufacture was not ‘embellishing’ the GN data
> The Flash is within Specification
> The Flash has recycled fully for each shot
> The guess that “4 Stops over ambient” is about correct (That guess might be wrong: if you need fewer than 4 Stops of Flash over Ambient then that's good, if you need more than 4 Stops of Flash over Ambient, then that's bad. Also note the amount of BLUR noticeable which is caused by Subject Movement is related to the SUBJECT DISTANCE and the DIRECTION OF MOTION in relation to the Lens's Axis and also the amount of Enlargement of the image and the Viewing Distance.
***
Using a Beamer:
A Flash Beamer will get you about another “1~2 Stops worth of flash power”. I like to think in GN. So that means a really REALLY good Beamer will give me 2 Stops and thus double the GN.
Let’s assume that it does give us 2 stops more "power" and we will b shooting at ISO1600 with your Altura Flash: F/10 @ 1/250s @ ISO1600, but now with an enhanced GN = 272 x 2 = 544.
So: 544/10 ≈ 54
So: WITH a really good “beamer” you’ll have a MAXIMUM FLASH WORKING DISTANCE of about 54metres (about 180 ft) at ISO 1600, and to do this you would pull the shot at: F/10 @ 1/250s @ ISO1600 . . .
Oh – but – remember:
You HAVE TO WAIT FOR THE FLASH TO RECYCLE BEFORE YOU CAN SHOOT AGAIN
***
High Speed Sync:
High Speed Sync is even more fun. What Manfred wrote – you’ll lose about 2 Stops worth of “flash power” (halve the GN) just by engaging HSS.
But HSS will really cause you grief apropos MFWD if you need you get the TV (Shutter Speed) much faster than HALF the X Flash Sync. Your X Flash Sync is 1/250s, so any Tv faster than about 1/800s will likely rip the guts out of your MFWD, depending upon the Speedlite that you use.
Oh – but – remember:
You HAVE TO WAIT FOR THE FLASH TO RECYCLE BEFORE YOU CAN SHOOT AGAIN
Also with HSS, even though most (all) have a cut-out switch to stop the Flash from frying, sometimes (not often but sometimes), it doesn't work: I had a colleague fry two 580's on the one shoot.
WW
N.B. I did quick mental arithmetic for all calcs and I haven't time to carefully proof read so - E. & O. E. if you find an error, please let me know, ta.