Originally Posted by
GrumpyDiver
A tricky set of shots, Tejal. The people are so large and the kites so small, that the context is not obvious at first glance.
The first shot with the silhouette is the strongest image, but the noise in the sky is quite noticeable, even at the size you have posted. There seem to be a few artifacts too; the face of the woman in the right, for instance. I suspect that trimming some of the black on the bottom of the shot might strengthen it too. There is a lot of black there and it really doesn't add to the image, I suspect.
The second shot is a bit strange; the "amputated" feet of the boys is striking and I find that there is simply too much negative space in the image, especially on the right. I like negative space, but it has to work, and I'm not sure that it does here.
The third shot is not working all that well for me either. You've worked to keep the kite in the shot, but it's contribution to the image is negligible. Again, too much negative space, I think.