I like your composition. And prefer the B&W - the colour has a little too much vibrance to my (current) taste
The colour image does it for me John. In the B&W the bulldozer is lost in the trucks behind. The clouds have enough pop for me in either version
It seems a shame to use it and get it all mucky.
I think it is what they call a fore end loader in this part of the world.
I hate to be the one to break it to you this John, but that is a loader Color for me too.
The colour one for me too John.
The complementary colour of the yellow front end loader against a (mostly) cool tone image works far better than the B&W image. Using complementary colours as a compositional technique doesn't work in monochrome.
Colour one for me too John...it breaks the blues and the whites and the rest of it too and to me it is a stronger image than the B/W.