Hi Susan .
I like the composition with the boughs of the tress seeming to form concentric arches around the shack and the line of vegetation at the base holding it all together, but I wonder if the full colour version would concentrate the eye more on the shack (assuming that is what you intended) because for me the mono (tinted) version is now of low overall contrast and the shack sort of melts into the foliage.
If you intend it to remain mono, I would burn in the edges (or vignette it ) and this would focus attention more on the shack.
A pleasant picture though thanks for sharing.
Hi John,
Thanks for your thoughts on this one, I appreciate it. My husband voted for the color version for those very reasons. Perhaps a better name would be Enveloped as that was how it all felt and looked to me and that was more my aim. For contrast I wanted to bring out the little bits of light on the path, sky and barn but am not sure I was terribly successful with that in PP. This does have a slight vignette but I didn't want to go heavy as the trees do most of work already and trees are my thing and are the subject just as much as the barn for me. I did brush in some areas darker as well. I think a darker vignette would make it even drearier. I am looking forward to going back here as it is close to home when there isn't so much smoke in the air..there are forest fires everywhere. Thanks much, Susan
Hi, Susan. I love the composition. Old buildings are typically a perfect opportunity for B/W. But as already suggested this particular situation may have been better served by color.
That looks like western Oregon ?
Well spotted and shot!
I thought I might post the color version for the heck of it but TinyPic says no..
Thank you for your comments Dan and Richard. Dan this is Southern Oregon - the Rogue Valley.
Beautiful composition. I'm a sucker for old barns . I agree that maybe a color version would separate the shack/barn from the tree landscape a bit more, and draw in more attention.
Thanks Sharon it's good to hear peoples reaction... I think it will be good to go and play with the color shot some more.
Very nice image.....but i am wondering how its original would be
I hope, maybe,you can try a very subtle version of this mono. This is a bit strong for my taste, maybe because I am just a simple person with a simple taste...or it might be my monitor. I will try to calibrate it again.
Thanks Nandakumar and Izzie it's great getting the feedback :-)
Last edited by Rainforest; 19th August 2017 at 03:01 PM.