Don't quite get what you mean here Ted.
Sorry, Bill. The image was posted here for C&C, like any other.
At the same time, having already posted it elsewhere, I wondered if a link to that image would work here - as opposed to having to upload it again - this time to my site - and linking to that, which is what I usually do.
Last edited by xpatUSA; 12th June 2020 at 03:44 PM.
The linking obviously worked.............
However, Ted, can't really offer C&C, but my heavens I like what you have produced.
Yes, I think you have given the right "impression" with this picture.
I will take the plunge and offer my C&C!
To my eye the painterly look is a rather like a masterpeice on anaglypta wallpaper rather than brush strokes. Sorry that sounds very harsh which was not my intention at all. It is the only analogy I can find to explain the impression it gives me. Another way to put it is that the "brushstrokes" seem a little formulaic in their size and texture which suggests the algorithm could be improved, not your use of it.
I might remove the leaning stem at the top which has no flowers attached to it.
Otherwise it works well as a change from the usual fare.
Well conceived and presented
It is my 'impression' that I like it
Cheers Ole
Thanks Ted - the link worked and all is revealed.
You are clearly enjoying yourself exploring "the GIMP", but this one didn't quite work for me - 'Painterly" yes, but it diidn't shout "Van Gogh". Looking forward to more though .
Thanks Nandakumar and Ole.
Rufus, thanks for the valid comments - and the image was indeed offered for a change.
Bill, fair comment re: Van Gogh. The faux brushwork is perhaps more reminiscent of Munch in "The Scream" or perhaps Gauguin's Market Gardens. Having said that, I am not particularly knowledgeable about any of these artists' work and the filter in the GIMP has a kajillion sliders some of which are not terribly intuitive.
Excuses ... excuses ...
Last edited by xpatUSA; 13th June 2020 at 09:42 AM.
That captures how I felt for the first 3 months or so after moving to LR+PS as my primary editors!
Turning to your request for C&C and with a focus on the "painterly" rather than "the painter", I pretty well agree with David, particularly about the dark diagonal stems top left. The "brush strokes" element may be worth exploring -perhaps push it some more?
The other thing about the image as posted is that if the intent is to mimic a painting then there should be no DoF sharpness fall-off and there appears to be quite a bit bottom left to top right.
Bill