I like #1 and #4 on this series, Rob. The water reflection on #1 compliment the way you composed the shot. As for #4, I like the way you used the moon and the fisherman as your contrasting subject. My only comment is that I wish you had included more shore detail so the fisherman is not totally at the far end corner of the frame for balance. Nice work!
Rob, here's one possible edit to the shot to make it balanced.
I added some shore area, Leveled the horizon and positioned it 1/3 from the bottom (using the rule of thirds in composition), moved the moon and its water reflection towards the inside of the frame for balance, and also I moved the fisherman a little bit for some drama. This is just a suggestion. Sometimes, it doesn't hurt to edit your work if necessary to bring out the vision that you had in your mind when you took the shot. Hope I did not offend you. Thanks.
Jiro,
Not offended at all. It does look much better. I think it's like writting, you write something and read it a bunch of times and you start to miss little things that a new reader would pick up on right away.
What program did you use for the edits?
Rob